Lessons from Curtis Yarvin

Curtis Yarvin, also known by his pseudonym Mencius Moldbug, is a political theorist and software developer known for his critique of modern democracy and his development of the neoreactionary (NRx) movement. His writings, primarily on his blogs Unqualified Reservations and Gray Mirror, offer a dense and often provocative analysis of power, history, and governance.

The Cathedral and the Media

The "Cathedral" is one of Yarvin's most famous concepts, describing what he sees as a decentralized but ideologically synchronized network of institutions—primarily academia and journalism—that shapes public opinion and holds the true power in Western societies.

Quotes:

"“The cathedral” is just a short way to say “journalism plus academia”—in other words, the intellectual institutions at the center of modern society, just as the Church was the intellectual institution at the center of medieval society." [1]
- Source: Gray Mirror, "A brief explanation of the cathedral," January 20, 2021. [1]
"The mystery of the cathedral is that all the modern world's legitimate and prestigious intellectual institutions, even though they have no central organizational connection, behave in many ways as if they were a single organizational structure." [1]
- Source: Gray Mirror, "A brief explanation of the cathedral," January 20, 2021. [1]
"In a democracy with a free press, the press is the government."
- Source: Unqualified Reservations, "Why there's no such thing as 'liberal media bias'," June 7, 2007.
"There is no way to receive a mainstream university education, read the Times every morning, trust both of them, and not be a progressive. Unless, of course, you're an idiot." [2]
- Source: Unqualified Reservations, "A gentle introduction to Unqualified Reservations (part 1)," April 8, 2009. [3]
"The entire intellectual system of the West was corrupted by its twentieth-century connection to government." [4]
- Source: Libertarianism, the Non-Aggression Axiom, and the State, as quoted on LibQuotes. [4]

Learnings:

The Cathedral as a Decentralized Power: Yarvin argues that true power in the modern West does not lie with elected officials but with a network of influential institutions (universities, media) that create and enforce social and political norms without any central command. [5][6]
Ideological Synchronization: Despite their apparent independence, these institutions tend to converge on a single, evolving progressive doctrine, creating a powerful, unified narrative that is difficult to challenge. [1]
The Illusion of a Free Press: What is called a "free press" is, in Yarvin's view, an integral part of the ruling structure, shaping public opinion to align with the Cathedral's ideology rather than acting as a neutral watchdog.
Progressivism as a Secular Religion: Yarvin views modern progressivism as a quasi-religious force, with its own dogmas and heresies, propagated by the Cathedral. [7]
The Cathedral's Self-Preservation: This system maintains power by defining the boundaries of acceptable thought and discrediting or "canceling" dissenting voices, ensuring its own ideological dominance. [6]

On Democracy and Governance

Yarvin is a staunch critic of democracy, which he views as an inefficient and ultimately destructive form of government. He proposes alternative models, most notably "neocameralism," where a country is run like a corporation.

Quotes:

"American democracy is a failed experiment." [8]
- Source: This is a central theme throughout his work, as summarized on his Wikipedia page. [8]
"Democracy is to power as a lottery is to money." [4]
- Source: As quoted on LibQuotes. [4]
"By handing a tiny slice of power to each of its residents, democracy performs the most essential task of a political structure: rewarding its supporters." [4]
- Source: Unqualified Reservations, "Democracy as a historical phenomenon," February 21, 2008. [2]
"If Americans want to change their government, they're going to have to get over their dictator phobia." [9]
- Source: As quoted on his Wikipedia page, this reflects his belief in the need for a strong, single executive. [9]
"There is no such thing as 'self-government'. Government is an organization that acts. So is Starbucks. Starbucks is not a democracy." [10]
- Source: As quoted on Wikiquote. [10]
"Stability is much underappreciated, especially by those who enjoy its benefits." [11]
- Source: As quoted on Goodreads. [11]
"The strong government executes firmly and decisively. The weak one is fickle and inconsistent, and as a result has to be much more vicious to achieve any given level of security."
- Source: Unqualified Reservations, "Against Political Freedom," October 18, 2007.
"Good government is effective, lawful government. Bad government is ineffective, lawless government."
- Source: Unqualified Reservations, "A gentle introduction to Unqualified Reservations (part 1)," April 8, 2009. [3]

Learnings:

Democracy as Inefficient: Yarvin argues that democracies are inherently inefficient, prone to gridlock, and unable to make long-term decisions, contrasting them with the efficiency of a corporate structure. [6][12]
Neocameralism: He proposes "neocameralism," a model where the state is restructured as a sovereign, joint-stock corporation. The country would be run by a CEO-monarch, accountable to shareholders, with the goal of being profitable and well-managed. [8][12]
The Illusion of Popular Control: The feeling of power that voters get from participating in elections is an illusion that serves to legitimize the existing power structure without giving citizens any real control. [2][4]
The Need for a Strong Executive: To fix a broken system, Yarvin advocates for a powerful, centralized executive—a monarch or CEO—who can act decisively without being hindered by democratic processes or bureaucracy. [5][8]
Government as a Business: Yarvin believes government should be viewed as a business that provides services to its "customers" (residents). If the government is run effectively, it will be stable and prosperous. [10]
Formalism: Yarvin calls for "formalism," which means aligning formal power with actual power. He argues that we should recognize who truly holds power and create a system that makes them accountable. [8]
RAGE (Retire All Government Employees): A provocative proposal to "reboot" the government by firing the entire federal bureaucracy and replacing it with a new, more efficient administration. [9]

On Power and Responsibility

Yarvin's analysis of power is central to his thought. He sees it as an inseparable combination of authority and responsibility.

Quotes:

"The secret of power is that power and responsibility are the same thing." [4]
- Source: As quoted on LibQuotes. [4]
"Hominids crave power, and they rationalize it as responsibility." [4]
- Source: As quoted on LibQuotes. [4]
"A good way to find the most powerful people in the US is to find the most responsible people."
- Source: Unqualified Reservations, "The clear pill: a simple introduction to formalism," April 24, 2008.
"Power corrupts not by repression, but by seduction." [4]
- Source: As quoted on LibQuotes. [4]
"Power is absolute. Power always wins. Power is always right. And if you think you're using power, power is using you." [13]
- Source: Gray Mirror, "A speech code for dissidents," February 20, 2021. [13]

Learnings:

Power and Responsibility are Inseparable: True power comes with absolute responsibility. Those who hold power are those who are ultimately responsible for the outcomes. [4]
The Sincerity of the Powerful: Yarvin argues that powerful people are almost always sincere in their belief that they are doing good. They rationalize their desire for power as a desire for responsibility to improve the world. [4]
Power is Not a Conspiracy: Power is not held by secret cabals scheming for control, but by those who openly work to "educate the public" and "make global policies," thereby taking on responsibility and thus gaining power.
The Nature of Political Change: Yarvin believes that power structures are not overthrown by direct opposition but tend to collapse on their own. The role of the dissident is not to fight power, but to outlive it. [13]

On Ideology and Truth

Yarvin often writes about the nature of belief, ideology, and the difficulty of perceiving reality through the fog of dominant narratives.

Quotes:

"[I]n many ways nonsense is a more effective organizing tool than the truth. Anyone can believe in the truth. To believe in nonsense is an unforgeable demonstration of loyalty." [14]
- Source: Unqualified Reservations, "An open letter to open-minded progressives," April 19, 2008. [14]
"Cthulhu may swim slowly. But he only swims left." [14]
- Source: Unqualified Reservations, "A gentle introduction to Unqualified Reservations (part 9)," May 28, 2009. This is a metaphor for the relentless, one-way direction of progressive change. [14]
"Reality is the perfect enemy: it always fights back, it can never be defeated, and infinite energy can be expended in unsuccessfully resisting it." [14]
- Source: Unqualified Reservations, "An open letter to open-minded progressives," April 19, 2008. [14]
"Lying is bad. Pretending is lying. Lying is bad, but it is especially bad to get in the habit of lying. It makes you weak. Weak doesn't win." [11]
- Source: Gray Mirror of the Nihilist Prince, as quoted on Goodreads. [11]
"The other day I was tinkering around in my garage and I decided to build a new ideology."
- Source: Unqualified Reservations, "A formalist manifesto," April 12, 2007. This is the opening line of his first major blog post.
"To be strong, get in the habit of only doing strong things, never weak things." [11]
- Source: Gray Mirror of the Nihilist Prince, as quoted on Goodreads. [11]

Learnings:

The Power of Nonsense: Shared belief in something nonsensical can be a powerful tool for group cohesion, as it acts as a costly and therefore honest signal of loyalty. [14]
The Red Pill: Yarvin popularized the "red pill" metaphor to describe the process of awakening from the illusions created by the Cathedral and seeing the underlying realities of power.
The Asymmetry of Political Change: He argues that political and social change has a strong and consistent leftward drift, a phenomenon he likens to entropy.
The Importance of Seeing Reality: A core theme in his work is the struggle to see the world as it is, rather than through the lens of prevailing ideologies.
Building a New Ideology: Yarvin's project from the beginning was not just to critique the present system, but to construct a new, more robust political framework from first principles.

On History and the Present

Yarvin frequently draws on historical examples, often from obscure sources, to support his arguments and re-frame the reader's understanding of the present.

Quotes:

"By my count, Anglophone North America ex Canada is on its fifth legal regime... The Fourth Republic is the New Deal regime, which illegally abolished the principle of limited government." [11]
- Source: As quoted on Goodreads, this reflects his view of American history as a series of revolutionary overthrows. [11]
"The relative peace of the last sixty years has been achieved only at the price of creating a university system which is an established church in all but name, and which suppresses any thought it finds even remotely disturbing."
- Source: Gene Expression, "Moral sentiments and Material Interests," October 5, 2006.
"The general modus operandi of the Progressive movement in attaining power was to cause problems, then appoint themselves to fix them." [10]
- Source: As quoted on Wikiquote. [10]
"Forget today's conservatives. They are simply not worth arguing with. They are the product of an adaptive environment which systematically rewards stupidity." [10]
- Source: As quoted on Wikiquote. [10]
"Every society in human history that has ever given itself over to government by intellectuals has lived to regret it. Ours will be no different."
- Source: Gene Expression, "Moral sentiments and Material Interests," October 5, 2006.

Learn more:

Lessons from Curtis Yarvin

The Cathedral and the Media

On Democracy and Governance

On Power and Responsibility

On Ideology and Truth

On History and the Present

Written by Antoine Buteau

Lessons from Slavo Zizek

Lessons from Sam Parr