Lessons from David Einhorn

David Einhorn, the founder of the prominent hedge fund Greenlight Capital, is a revered figure in the investment world, known for his meticulous research, value-oriented approach, and high-profile activist campaigns. His insights, often shared through shareholder letters, interviews, and his book, "Fooling Some of the People All of the Time," offer a treasure trove of wisdom for aspiring and seasoned investors alike.

Value Investing Philosophy

Einhorn's approach is rooted in traditional value investing, but with his own unique spin. He emphasizes a deep understanding of a company's intrinsic worth and is disciplined about the price he is willing to pay.

On the core of value investing: "We're a value investor. We are long and we're short... our goal is to buy things that we think are undervalued and are likely to do well as a result of being undervalued." [1]
Inverting the typical value process: "The traditional value investor asks 'Is this cheap?' and then 'Why is it cheap?' We start by identifying a reason something might be mispriced, and then if we find a reason why something is likely mispriced, then we make a determination whether it's cheap." [2][3] This inverted process helps in identifying structural reasons for mispricing, such as mergers, spin-offs, or complexity that other investors may overlook. [3]
The importance of a margin of safety: Einhorn's strategy involves buying stocks at a discount to their intrinsic value, which serves as a risk management technique to lower potential losses. [4]
Focus on long-term growth potential: He believes in identifying undervalued companies that also possess strong fundamentals and the potential for long-term growth. [5]
Evolving his style for a changing market: "We have become even more disciplined about price and emphasize investments where we get paid by the issuers, as opposed to relying on other investors to revalue the security." (Greenlight Capital Q4 2023 Letter) [6]
Patience is a virtue: Einhorn's investment in Green Brick Partners (GRBK) showcases his long-term perspective, holding the stock for years and seeing substantial gains. [4]
Deep fundamental analysis is non-negotiable: Before making any investment, Einhorn and his team meticulously examine a company's financial statements, management, competitive landscape, and industry dynamics. [5][7]
Understanding the business is key: His successful long-term investment in Tenet Healthcare (THC) was based on a deep understanding of the healthcare utilization environment and the company's operational improvements. [6]
Look for companies with high returns on equity: Einhorn has referenced Joel Greenblatt's concept of investing in great companies, which are often those that can generate high profits without requiring a lot of capital. [8]
The challenge of value investing in modern markets: Einhorn has noted that the rise of passive and quantitative investing has made the market less focused on fundamental value, making it a tougher environment for traditional value investors. [6][9]

Contrarian Thinking & Short-Selling

Einhorn is perhaps most famous for his contrarian bets and his willingness to short-sell companies he believes are overvalued or engaged in questionable practices.

The job of an investor: "As an investor my job is to figure out what will happen rather than what should happen." [10][11] This highlights the need to analyze market dynamics realistically rather than based on idealistic expectations.
The rationale for shorting: "We're not critical of this company because we are short; we are short because we are critical of this company." (Fooling Some of the People All of the Time) [12] This quote from his book emphasizes that his short positions are the result of critical analysis, not the cause of it.
Challenging the consensus: Einhorn is known for taking positions that go against popular market sentiment, which allows him to identify mispriced assets. [5]
Shorting is not just about valuation: "We generally don't short stocks just on valuation. But when we came to a point with certain stocks that the valuation was so extremely out of whack... it was 90% or so overvalued. You don't need a computer to help you figure that out." [3]
The famous Lehman Brothers short: One of his most celebrated moves was shorting Lehman Brothers in 2007 after identifying significant red flags in their balance sheet that the broader market had missed. [4][5]
Identifying "bubble baskets": Einhorn has been known to short baskets of what he deems to be overvalued "story stocks," particularly during periods of market froth. [13]
The pain of a losing short: In his Q4 2023 letter, he candidly discussed the difficulty of holding short positions in a bull market, noting that four of his shorts had cost the fund significantly. [6]
Activist investing as a tool: Einhorn doesn't just passively invest; he will actively engage with companies to push for changes that he believes will unlock shareholder value. [4][5]
On market inefficiencies: "I was never a believer that the markets are efficient." [11][14] This belief underpins his search for mispriced opportunities.
The danger of "story stocks": Einhorn has expressed skepticism about companies that are propelled more by narrative than by solid fundamentals, a common theme in his short positions. [15]

Risk Management & The Poker Analogy

An avid poker player, Einhorn frequently draws parallels between the card game and investing, emphasizing incomplete information, psychological edges, and disciplined risk management.

The similarity in skillsets: "Both poker and investing are games of incomplete information. You have a certain set of facts and you are looking for situations where you have an edge, whether the edge is psychological or statistical." [2][8]
Knowing when you're wrong: "The best advice I've ever received in managing the portfolio is as soon as you know that you're wrong, change your mind." [16] He stresses that there is no shame in being wrong and that the biggest mistake is sticking to a losing position after realizing the initial thesis was flawed. [1][16]
The frequency of being wrong: "If we do a really, really good job, we're going to be right 65 or 70% of the time, which means we're going to be wrong 30, 35% of the time." [1][16] This highlights the importance of managing the downside of incorrect decisions.
A strict exit rule: "We try not to have many investing 'rules,' but there is one that has served us well: If we decide we were wrong about something, in terms of why we did it, we exit, period." [2]
The danger of inventing new reasons: "We never invent new reasons to continue with a position when the original reasons are no longer available." [2][10]
Position sizing matters: Einhorn pays close attention to how much capital he allocates to each idea, putting the most money into his highest-conviction investments. [2][4]
The airbag analogy for risk models: "A 99% Value-at-Risk calculation does not evaluate what happens in the last one percent… This is like an airbag that works all the time, except when you have a car accident." [8][11] This criticizes over-reliance on simplistic risk models that fail in extreme scenarios.
Long-short strategy as a hedge: By taking both long and short positions, Einhorn aims to reduce overall market exposure and generate returns in both bull and bear markets. [4][7]
The compounding of losses: "What do you call a stock that's down 90%? A stock that was down 80% and then got cut in half." [8][10] A stark reminder of how quickly losses can escalate.
The difference in time horizon: "With poker, you have a resolution of the hand within a couple of minutes. Whereas, even if the thought process in investing is very much the same, you're looking at an outcome that could be 2, 3, 4, 5 years from when you make the original decision." [2]

Market Insights & Psychology

Einhorn often provides insightful commentary on broader market trends, investor behavior, and the psychological pitfalls that can trap even sophisticated market participants.

On market extremes: "Market extremes occur when it becomes too expensive in the short-term to hold for the long-term." [11][14]
The "Jelly Donut" policy: In a critique of the Federal Reserve's monetary policy, he compared excessive easing to force-feeding jelly donuts, where too much of a good thing becomes destructive. [8][14]
On the brokenness of the market: "The stock market is fundamentally broken!" (Greenlight Capital Q1 2024 Letter) [8] He argues that the dominance of passive and non-valuation-based investors has distorted price discovery. [6][8]
The danger of "this time it's different": "The most dangerous words in investing are 'this time it's different.'" [17] A classic warning against ignoring historical precedents.
The influence of narratives: He acknowledges that people in the market often say things they don't believe to be true, both to promote and to criticize stocks. [11][14]
Time arbitrage as an inefficiency: "I think one of the inefficiencies in the market is investors are generically too short-term oriented and time arbitrage is one of the best inefficiencies in the market." [3]
On the return of "animal spirits": In his Q4 2023 letter, he noted that "bubble-like conditions returned for the most speculative stocks," indicating a return of speculative fervor in certain market pockets. [15]
The importance of humility: Einhorn's writings and interviews often convey a sense of humility, acknowledging that he is often wrong and must constantly question his own assumptions. [16]
Observing the masters: He has noted Warren Buffett's market timing, observing that Buffett's portfolio adjustments often signal a long-term view on market valuations. [18]
The social repugnance of certain businesses: Einhorn has stated that he avoids investing in certain industries, like payday lending, that he finds "so socially repugnant," regardless of the potential economics. [19]

Lessons from Experience

Einhorn's career has been marked by both spectacular successes and challenging periods of underperformance. His reflections on these experiences offer valuable lessons in resilience and adaptability.

On naming the firm: "When you leave a good job to go off on your own and don't expect to make money for a while, you name the firm whatever your wife says you should." (Fooling Some of the People All of the Time) [3] A humorous take on the entrepreneurial leap.
The importance of transparency: "If you develop a reputation for candor with securities analysts and investors, that's about the best you can do." (Fooling Some of the People All of the Time) [12]
On handling underperformance: In a 2015 letter, after a tough year, he acknowledged that having his worst-performing investments among his biggest positions was a key reason for the poor results, a risk inherent in a concentrated portfolio. [15]
The cyclical nature of investment styles: "Our view is that over time, value investing is more successful than investment strategies that ignore value... We don't know when the winds will change, but we know that they will." [15]
Learning from losses: "The loss was not bad luck. It was bad analysis." [10][11] This demonstrates his commitment to taking responsibility for his mistakes.
On starting Greenlight Capital: He started the fund in 1996 with $900,000, feeling there was little risk because he could likely return to a similar job if it failed. [16][19]
The value of a supportive culture: "For one thing, Greenlight only hires nice people... we actively look to hire people who are nice." [2] He believes this fosters a culture of respect and critical thinking. [16]
On philanthropy: Einhorn has expressed a commitment to philanthropy, believing it's important to be generous and make a difference, especially given his financial success. [19]
The challenge of a concentrated portfolio: "These aren't our first big losses nor are they likely to be our last, and while our goal is to minimize them, they come with the territory of running a concentrated portfolio." [15]
The importance of intellectual honesty: A recurring theme throughout his work is the necessity of being intellectually honest with oneself, especially when an investment is not working out as planned. [20]

Learn more:

Lessons from David Einhorn

Value Investing Philosophy

Contrarian Thinking & Short-Selling

Risk Management & The Poker Analogy

Market Insights & Psychology

Lessons from Experience

Written by Antoine Buteau

Lessons from Jesse Livermore

Lessons from Andrew Left