Lessons from Ernest Garcia II and III

Ernest Garcia III, the CEO and co-founder of Carvana, and his father, Ernest Garcia II, the founder of DriveTime and a major investor in Carvana, have reshaped the used car industry through a potent combination of technological innovation and a deep-seated focus on customer experience. While both are known for maintaining a relatively private profile, their interviews and the principles embedded in their companies offer a wealth of knowledge for entrepreneurs and business leaders.

Ernest Garcia III: Quotes and Learnings on Leadership, Strategy, and Disruption

As the public face of Carvana, Ernest Garcia III has shared numerous insights into the company's meteoric rise, its near-death experiences, and its foundational principles.

On Entrepreneurship and Vision

On the Nature of Entrepreneurs: "I think entrepreneurs are essentially stubborn egomaniacs. You have to have a big enough ego to believe you can change things. And you have to be stubborn enough to keep fighting for it when it gets hard." [1]
The Pursuit of Fulfillment: "To find outside success, the results of your actions have to be positive for other people...you have to put yourself in battles...and find that fulfillment and satisfaction." [2]
The Inevitability of Challenges: "I just think that the truth is there are almost no businesses that don't go through something very difficult. and so I just think that...you just have to know that's part of the journey." [3]
The Importance of Believing in Your Path: "I think most companies that take a big swing generally have multiple near-death experiences. and so I think avoiding...one extra one to to kind of sacrifice the things you deeply believe is is not worth it." [2]
On Facing Skepticism: "If I were to try to frame it more positively. I I would just. say. I've made peace with the fact that people are going to question you if you're ever doing anything that matters." [4]

On Leadership and Culture

The Essence of Company Culture: "What matters is when you're sitting in a room of six people and you're doing. things. what is normal in that room that's what your culture is." [3]
Building a Resilient Team: A key to navigating crises is having a team of resilient individuals with a "sports mentality" who can maintain morale and focus. [5]
The Power of a Shared Mission: To weather difficult times, it's crucial to build a foundation where the team believes in the consumer direction of the company and there is a deep sense of trust within the group. [3]
On His Leadership Style (Self-Awareness): "I'm excitable...and I want to work on the next cool thing...my instinct is to jump to the next thing too fast...prioritization. and follow through are very very important...and I think that that's not my relative strength." [3]
The Importance of "Player-Coach" Leadership: Garcia emphasizes the need for leaders to be close to the work and the people executing it, as opposed to managing from a distance. [6]
Real Mentoring is in the Trenches: "Real mentoring isn't about sitting in a room and telling people the rules. it's about being there solving a problem and having a person watch the problem be solved." [3]
Hiring for Cultural Fit: When assessing a company's culture during an interview, observe the dynamics between junior and senior employees; confident junior members often indicate a healthy culture. [3]
Retaining Talent in Tough Times: A reason for the longevity of Carvana's executive team is that they are not primarily motivated by status, which helps prevent disintegration when the company faces difficulties. [2]

On Business Strategy and Innovation

Customer Experience is Paramount: "Our view is it doesn't have much to do with the product...The customer experience is at the root." [7]
The Rationale for Vertical Integration: "We don't believe you can give customers the experience that we want to give them unless you do it all." [4]
The Power of a Differentiated Business Model: To offer customers a better deal, a simpler experience, and a broader selection, while also achieving higher returns, you must build a completely different business model. [8]
Investing in the Customer Experience as Marketing: "The best like dollars you can spend in marketing are generally improving the customer. experience...it's kind of like a...linear. relationship instead of like an exponential payoff." [3]
The Strategic Value of the Car Vending Machine: "The Car Vending Machine gives us, essentially, a permanent billboard, a customer purchase fulfillment location and a signature element that represents the brand and aids in PR." [1]
The Long-Term View on Problem-Solving: "Trying to thoughtfully think through that machine and then recognize that there's a hundred problems you have to solve to do that really well, and trying to do your best to size and sort them from most important to least important is I think a huge part of what success is." [5]
The Continuous Cycle of Improvement: "Every time you solve a problem you see two new opportunities." [5]
The Importance of Saying "No": Learning to decline certain projects is crucial for maintaining focus on high-priority initiatives and avoiding unnecessary complexity. [6]
On Operators vs. Strategists: "If you can pick one. I think you want operators like operators get things done and operators focus on the practical...I think that you you must have that to succeed." [4]
The Advantage of Vertical Integration in an AI-Driven World: As AI becomes more important, vertical integration becomes a better answer because it overcomes the friction between different horizontal business layers. [3]

On Overcoming Adversity

The Mindset in a Crisis: When facing a downturn, it's crucial to shut out the external noise and focus on the fundamental truths of the business that were present during successful periods. [9]
The Crisis as a Defining Moment: "The moment where it's hard is the most important moment in the entire business's. history and so in a funny way it's almost like an exciting moment because it's like it's the moment where you either win or you lose." [3]
Finding Strength in Being the Underdog: Going through a period where no one believes in you can create a strong bond within the team and a renewed sense of motivation, akin to a startup mentality. [9]

Ernest Garcia II: Learnings from a Career of Building and Investing

While Ernest Garcia II is less public than his son, his business acumen and strategic vision laid the groundwork for Carvana's success. His "learnings" are primarily derived from his business strategies and investment philosophy.

Business Philosophy and Strategy

Focus on Long-Term Growth and Innovation: Garcia II's investment philosophy centers on identifying and backing industries undergoing digital transformation for long-term growth. [10]
Identifying and Serving Underserved Markets: The success of DriveTime was built on catering to customers with limited credit histories, a segment largely overlooked by traditional dealerships. [10]
The Power of Vertical Integration: DriveTime's model of combining vehicle sales with in-house financing demonstrates a long-held belief in the power of controlling the entire customer journey. [11]
Transforming a Bankrupt Business into a Market Leader: Garcia II's acquisition of the bankrupt Ugly Duckling rent-a-car franchise and its transformation into DriveTime showcases his ability to see potential and execute a turnaround. [8][12]
Strategic Use of Public and Private Markets: Garcia II has demonstrated a willingness to take companies public to raise capital and private to restructure and grow, as seen with Ugly Duckling/DriveTime. [8][12]
Calculated Risk-Taking: His career, including a conviction for bank fraud early on, shows a high tolerance for risk and the ability to rebound from significant setbacks. [8]
The Importance of a Proprietary System: DriveTime's success was bolstered by its proprietary credit scoring model, allowing it to effectively manage risk in the subprime market. [11]
Building a Foundation for Future Ventures: The infrastructure and expertise developed at DriveTime were instrumental in the initial funding and operational support of Carvana. [12][13]

Carvana's Core Values: The Garcia Philosophy in Practice

The official values of Carvana reflect the principles championed by the Garcias and are a key part of their "learnings."

Your next customer may be your mom.
We're all in this together.
Be brave.
There are no sidelines.
Zag forward.
Don't be a Richard.

These values are communicated as central to the company's culture and decision-making processes. [Source: Comparably, "Carvana Mission, Vision & Values"]

Additional Learnings from the Garcia Playbook

The Synergy of Family Businesses: The close collaboration between DriveTime and Carvana in the early years provided Carvana with a significant competitive advantage in terms of inventory and financing. [12]
Adaptability in the Face of Market Shifts: The Garcias have shown a consistent ability to adapt their business models to changing economic conditions and consumer behaviors. [14]
The Strategic Importance of Physical Infrastructure: Despite being an online retailer, Carvana's investment in physical assets like inspection centers and car vending machines is a key part of its strategy. [1]
Focus on Efficiency as a Driver of Profitability: In recent years, Carvana has shifted its focus from hypergrowth to operational efficiency to drive profitability. [15]
The Value of a Strong Brand Identity: The iconic car vending machines have been a powerful tool for building brand awareness and creating a unique customer experience. [1]
Long-Term Perspective on Market Volatility: Ernest Garcia III has repeatedly emphasized the importance of focusing on long-term goals rather than reacting to short-term market fluctuations. [6]
The Power of Data and Technology: From DriveTime's proprietary credit models to Carvana's online platform, the use of technology to gain an edge has been a constant theme. [10]
Generosity as a Leadership Trait: In 2018, Ernest Garcia III gave $35 million of his personal stock to Carvana employees to celebrate a company milestone. [16]
Resilience in the Face of Public Scrutiny: Both Garcias have navigated significant public and legal challenges throughout their careers, demonstrating a high degree of resilience. [8]
The Unwavering Belief in a Better Customer Experience: At the heart of both DriveTime and Carvana is the fundamental belief that the traditional car-buying process is broken and can be significantly improved for the customer. [7]

Learn more: