Lessons from Jim Chanos

Jim Chanos, the legendary American investment manager and founder of Kynikos Associates, has built a formidable reputation as one of the world's most prominent short-sellers. His career is distinguished by his early and vocal skepticism of companies that later collapsed under the weight of financial fraud and flawed business models, most famously Enron. Chanos's investment philosophy, centered on deep forensic analysis of financial statements and a cynical view of market exuberance, offers a treasure trove of wisdom for any investor.

On the Philosophy of Short-Selling and the Market

On the role of short-sellers: "Short sellers are the professional skeptics who look past the hype to gauge the true value of a stock." [1]
The lonely crusade: "If you're a short-seller, that's a cacophony of negative reinforcement. You're basically told that you're wrong in every way imaginable every day. It takes a certain type of individual to drown that noise and negative reinforcement out and to remind oneself that their work is accurate and what they're hearing is not." [1]
The financial detectives: "The most important function that fundamental short sellers bring to the market is that they are real time financial detectives." [2] Chanos argues that while regulators are often "financial archeologists" who figure out what happened years later, short-sellers are on the front lines as it unfolds. [3]
A necessary evil: "I'll always understand the Schadenfreude aspect to short-selling. I get that no one will always like it. I'm also convinced to the deepest part of my bones that short-selling plays the role of real-time financial watchdog. It's one of the few checks and balances in the market." [1][2]
The nature of bubbles: "Bubbles are best identified by credit excesses, not valuation excesses. And there's no bigger credit excess than in China." [1][2]
Defining a bubble: "What we define as a bubble is any kind of debt-fueled asset inflation where the cash flow generated by the asset itself – a rental property, office building, condo – does not cover the debt incurred to buy the asset. So you depend on a greater fool, if you will, to come in and buy at a higher price." [1]
The "Golden Age of Fraud": "I’ve called this the golden age of fraud. I think there’s more fraud in the financial markets now than there has ever been." [4] He attributes this to a long bull market eroding disbelief and an increased willingness to buy into narratives over fundamentals. [5][6]
The market's memory: "The longer the cycle goes...the more people's sense of disbelief is eroded right they begin to believe things that are too good to be true you know FOMO is the current term." [6]
On market timing: "The one thing I've learned after 40 years of running money is that my idea of where the markets are going is pretty much worthless." [7]
Risk vs. Timing: "Price levels and and the and where we are in that part of the cycle. don't give you a good sense of timing. they do give you a good sense of how much risk you're taking should the timing change." [8]
The nature of a bull market: "Bull markets place a premium on promises and bear markets discount reality." [8]

On Investment Strategy and Research

The starting point of research: "Nothing beats starting with source documents." [2]
The importance of primary research: "Primary research is crucial and not as many people do it as you think." [2]
Focus on the fundamentals: "We try to focus on businesses where something is going wrong." [2][9]
The language of business: "At the end of the day, the language of business is numbers… If you're not very comfortable with understanding how companies can play games with their financial statements using GAAP accounting, you're never going to be a good short-seller." [9]
The asymmetry of information: "If you are a fundamental short seller you have no problem finding out what the bull case is. If you are long a stock, knowing what the bear case is takes work." [9]
On valuation: "Everybody says be careful shorting on valuation and I think that's a good bromide." [9] Chanos emphasizes that valuation alone is a dangerous reason to short a stock. [9]
The core of his strategy: Chanos describes his investment strategy as "intensive research into stocks", looking for fundamental failures in market valuation, from underestimated or unreported failings in the business or the market of a particular stock. [10]
The psychological makeup of a short-seller: "I used to think that good short-sellers could be trained... But now I've learned that there's a big difference between a long-focused value investor and a good short-seller. That difference is psychological..." [11]
Born, not made: "I think that good short sellers are born, not made, quite frankly. I never used to think that. But I do think that now, after 30 years of doing this." [12]
The danger of "smart guy syndrome": Chanos warns against following respected investors into a stock without doing your own research, noting that every major stock collapse often has a well-known investor on the register. [13]
The problem with EBITDA: "You should always be sceptical of valuation metrics that use earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA), or 'earnings before expenses' as it's often derided." [13]

Learnings from Famous Shorts

The Enron Revelation: A key red flag for Chanos in the Enron case was the company's low return on capital despite its reputation as a dominant force. He noted it was earning about a 6% pre-tax return on its capital, which was too low for a company supposedly revolutionizing its industry. [6][14]
Enron's Accounting Games: Chanos was initially tipped off by an article about "gain-on-sale" accounting, which allowed energy trading firms like Enron to book profits from long-term trades years before the cash came in. [14]
Executive Departures as a Major Red Flag: Speaking about his Tesla short, Chanos stated, "Probably the number one sign of impending problems is mass executive departures. I don't mean one or two people, I mean 30 or 40." [15]
Carvana as a "Subprime Lender": Chanos's thesis on Carvana is that it's not a tech disruptor but a "subprime lender masquerading as a used car dealer." [16] He argues that "Carvana is making all this money in finance, not selling cars." [1][4]
Carvana's Aggressive Accounting: He argues that Carvana's gross profit margins are a product of aggressive accounting that inflates profitability while excluding many costs that other auto dealers typically include. [1][17]
Insider Selling at Carvana: "Perhaps more ominous is that insiders have begun to sell an absolute torrent of stock—pretty much the whole C-suite is getting out seemingly as fast as they can." [1]
The Pain of the Tesla Short: Despite his conviction, Chanos admitted the Tesla short was "painful." [7] He began shorting the stock in 2016 but had to reduce the position before its inclusion in the S&P 500 in 2020. [11][17]
Tesla's Overstated Gross Margins: Chanos criticized Tesla for not including R&D and other costs in its gross margin calculations, which he said inflates them by as much as 10 percentage points compared to other automakers. [10]
The "Treadmill to Hell" in China: Chanos famously warned that China's real-estate excesses had placed it on a "treadmill to hell" and that a bubble could burst at any point. [18]
Wirecard Was "Never Profitable": After the collapse of the German payments company, Chanos stated his belief that "Wirecard was never profitable." [18]
Learning from Baldwin-United: One of his earliest successes came from analyzing Baldwin-United, a piano company turned insurance giant. He realized its financials were a sham, a discovery that helped launch his career in short-selling. [5]

On Accounting and Red Flags

The Accounting Tail Wagging the Economic Dog: This phrase captures his view that accounting choices can distort the true economic reality of a business. [2]
Management's Responsibility: When he asks his students who is responsible for ensuring financial statements are accurate, most say the auditors. He corrects them, stating it is management's responsibility, and that major frauds are typically perpetrated by the highest levels of management. [19]
Growth by Acquisition: Chanos calls this "one of the last great legal areas of fraud," where companies use M&A to either enrich executives or hide accounting problems. [3]
Philanthropy as a Red Flag: Chanos has noted that philanthropy can be used as a shield by corporate wrongdoers to create a positive public image. [3]
Confusing Disclosures and Nonsensical GAAP: These are key red flags that can obscure a company's true financial health. [13]
Questioning Pro-Forma Metrics: He was highly critical of Valeant Pharmaceuticals for its use of "pro-forma cash EPS," which he saw as a poster child for misleading, non-GAAP reporting. [20]
The Unpredictable Risks: "The real risks will be something... that comes out of left field that changes people's thinking. By definition, we do not know what that is." [18]

General Wisdom and Commentary

On Derivatives: "Derivatives in and of themselves are not evil. There's nothing evil about how they're traded, how they're accounted for, and how they're financed, like any other financial instrument, if done properly." [1][2]
On the Printing Press: "The Fed is not the only one with the printing press. Wall Street does a pretty good job at issuing pieces of paper when people really want them." [16]
The Importance of Skepticism: "If we cannot differentiate valuations, capitalism is broken. You do not want to be sending a lot of money to Enron and Theranos. You want to send it to the Amazons." [18]
On China's Reporting Standards: In response to a suggestion that the U.S. adopt a semi-annual reporting system similar to China's, Chanos stated, "China should NOT be the standard for our financial reporting." [21]
On the AI Boom: Chanos has expressed skepticism about the AI boom, suggesting that many companies benefiting from the hype will end up as "roadkill on the AI highway." [4]
On the futility of predicting markets: "And where the stock market's going, I have no idea. I started my firm back in 1985. The Dow was 1300. So I mean, that should tell you something about timing." [16][21]
Most companies underperform: "...with the exception of the far right group of companies on the bell curve, most companies underperformed the stock market over time or fail." [15][16]
The value of portfolio insurance: "People insure their homes, they insure their cars, they insure their loved ones... it's pretty cheap right now to ensure a portfolio." [15][21]
On the changing landscape of short-selling: "It's no secret that the long/short stock business model is under pressure, and investors' interest in fundamental stock selection is waning." [11]
The enduring nature of fraud: "The techniques change and the stories change, but in bear markets people want profits and cash flow... in bull markets they'll pay up for dreams." [6]

Learn more:

Lessons from Jim Chanos

On the Philosophy of Short-Selling and the Market

On Investment Strategy and Research

Learnings from Famous Shorts

On Accounting and Red Flags

General Wisdom and Commentary

Written by Antoine Buteau

Lessons from Carlota Perez

Lessons from Jesse Livermore