Lessons from Nick Kolenda

Nick Kolenda, a prominent marketing psychologist, has carved a niche for himself by dissecting the intricate workings of the human mind and translating those insights into actionable strategies for persuasion, pricing, and consumer choice. His work, primarily disseminated through his detailed blog posts and books, offers a treasure trove of knowledge for marketers, business owners, and anyone interested in the science of influence.

On Persuasion and Influence

The foundation of Kolenda's teachings lies in his "METHODS" acronym, a seven-step process for influencing behavior. [1][2]

M - Mold Their Perception: Before you make a request, shape the lens through which your target sees the world. [2][3] This can be achieved through techniques like priming and anchoring. [4]
E - Elicit Congruent Attitudes: Encourage attitudes that align with your desired outcome. [5] People strive for consistency between their actions and beliefs. [2]
T - Trigger Social Pressure: Leverage social influence to guide behavior. We are inherently social creatures influenced by the actions and opinions of others. [4][5]
H - Habituate Your Message: Familiarity breeds liking. Repeated exposure to a message or concept can increase its acceptance. [2]
O - Optimize Your Message: Tailor your message for maximum impact, considering factors like argument strength and presentation aesthetics. [2][5]
D - Drive Their Momentum: Guide people toward a specific outcome by building on small commitments. [5]
S - Sustain Their Compliance: Ensure that the change in behavior or attitude is lasting. [5]

Key Learnings in Persuasion:

On High Expectations: "If you want people to perceive something more favorably, you should convey high expectations because those expectations will become a lens that will mold their perception." [6]
The Power of Priming: Casually introducing concepts or words related to a desired mindset can influence subsequent behavior. For instance, talking about open-mindedness can make someone more receptive to a new idea. [7]
Anchoring in Negotiations: The first number presented in a negotiation heavily influences the final outcome. Starting with a high anchor can make subsequent, lower numbers seem more reasonable. [4]
The Foot-in-the-Door Technique: Gaining compliance with a small request increases the likelihood of agreement with a subsequent larger request. [5]
The Lowball Technique: Once a person has agreed to an initial, attractive offer, they are more likely to accept a less favorable revision of that offer. [5]
Insufficient Justification: "In order to create the greatest change in your target's attitude, you need 'insufficient justification' – your incentive must be small or nonexistent so that your target attributes his compliance toward a genuine desire to comply, not toward a desire to receive the external reward." [6][8]
The Danger of Large Incentives: "Perhaps the most direct reason why large incentives can be ineffective is that they sometimes increase anxiety levels." [7]
The Chameleon Effect: People non-consciously mimic the non-verbal behaviors of those they are interacting with, which can be used to build rapport and increase agreement. [9]

On Pricing Psychology

Kolenda's work on pricing is extensive, revealing how subtle cues can drastically alter our perception of value. [10]

Price is a Perception: "At the end of the day, price is merely a perception. Nothing more. Nothing less." [11]
The Power of a Small Font: Displaying prices in a smaller font size can make them seem numerically smaller. [11][12]
The Left-Digit Effect: Reducing the left-most digit of a price (e.g., $2.99 vs. $3.00) has a significant impact on perception, even if the actual difference is minimal. [11]
The Fluency of Fewer Syllables: Prices with fewer syllables are perceived as being lower. Our brains process them more easily, and this fluency is misattributed to a lower value. [13]
Removing the Comma: Prices without a comma (e.g., $1500 vs. $1,500) are often perceived as being lower. [11][13]
The Precision of Large Prices: For large purchases, using a precise number (e.g., $34,875) can be more effective than a rounded number because it suggests careful calculation and legitimacy. [11]
The Charm of Rounded Prices for Emotional Purchases: Conversely, rounded numbers are often more effective for emotional or hedonic purchases. [11]
Mentioning the Daily Equivalence: Breaking down a large price into its daily or monthly cost can make it seem more manageable (e.g., "just $1 a day"). [11]
The Decoy Effect: Offering a third, asymmetrically dominated option can steer customers towards the option you want them to choose. [14]
The Pain of Paying: Strategies like pre-payment can reduce the "pain of paying" by separating the payment from the consumption experience. [15]
The Visual Contrast of Discounts: Making the sale price look visually different from the original price (e.g., different color, size) can enhance the perception of a good deal. [13]
The Power of Red Prices for Men: Research suggests that men may be more drawn to prices displayed in red. [11]
The "Time vs. Money" Effect: For experiential products, emphasizing the time spent enjoying the product can be more persuasive than highlighting its monetary value. [11]
Charging Before Consumption: People tend to be happier with a product or service if they prepay for it, as it allows them to focus on the benefits rather than the cost. [15]
Don't Bundle Cheap and Expensive Items: Bundling a high-value item with a low-value one can devalue the more expensive product in the consumer's mind. [11]

On Choice and Consumer Behavior

Kolenda delves into the cognitive processes that drive our decisions, offering ways to guide those choices.

The Simulation Heuristic: "Before you make a decision, you imagine the process and outcome to gauge your emotional reaction. If this imagery feels vivid and pleasant, then you confirm the decision." [3]
The Central Gaze Cascade Effect: Options placed in the center of an assortment are more likely to be chosen because they receive more visual attention. [14][16]
The Importance of a "Which-to-Choose" Mindset: Activating a mindset of choosing between options, rather than whether to choose at all, can increase the likelihood of a purchase. [16]
Gamifying the Choice: Making the decision process feel like a game can increase engagement and influence the final choice. [16]
The Power of Assertive Language for Emotional Products: When promoting products that are purchased based on emotion, using assertive and confident language can be more effective. [16]
Reducing the Guilt of Emotional Choices: Offering a charitable incentive alongside a luxury or emotional purchase can help alleviate guilt and increase the likelihood of purchase. [16]
The Impact of Sensory Cues: Distinguishing a target option with sensory cues like color, size, or shape can capture attention and increase its selection. [16]
The Influence of Product Arrangement: Arranging products in a logical sequence (e.g., shampoo then conditioner) or a visually appealing pattern can increase sales. [12]
The Paradox of Choice: While some choice is good, offering too many options can lead to decision paralysis and reduced sales. Kolenda suggests humans can comfortably handle about four options. [13]
The Value of In-App Balances: Allowing customers to pay with an existing in-app balance can increase sales as it feels less like spending real money. [13]

On Advertising and Marketing Communication

Kolenda's insights extend to how we craft and deliver marketing messages for maximum effectiveness.

Website Aesthetics as a Heuristic for Quality: "Website aesthetics are crucial for a number of reasons. First, people use aesthetics as a heuristic for quality; if your website is aesthetically pleasing, they'll assume your content is above average, and vice versa." [6]
The Power of Italics for Urgency: Using italics can create a sense of movement and urgency, prompting faster action. [13]
Grayscale Ads for Future Purchases: For products or events that will occur in the distant future, grayscale ads can be more effective as they align with our less vivid mental imagery of the future. [13]
The Present Tense for Services: Describing services in the present tense (e.g., "the new toilet looks good") can make them feel more valuable and ongoing. [13]
The Surprising Downside of Humans in Product Images: For some products on platforms like Instagram, images without people may perform better as the human element can distract from the product itself. [13]
The Importance of a Strong First Impression: People form opinions quickly, so the initial information presented will heavily influence their perception of everything that follows. [4]
Mentioning Negatives to Increase Credibility: Including minor negative points in a message can make the overall argument seem more realistic and trustworthy. [2]
The Effectiveness of In-Content Advertising: Integrating advertisements in a way that they resemble the content the user is already consuming can be more effective than jarring, interruptive ads. [9]
Mimicking Physical Actions in a Digital Context: Product images should allow for a mental simulation of real-world interaction. For example, an image of a pillow should convey its fluffiness. [12]
Pushing Attention to Calls to Action: The call to action should be the most visually prominent element, as attention is often misattributed as desire. [12]

Nick Kolenda's work is a continuous exploration of the "why" behind human behavior. By understanding these deep-seated psychological principles, we can communicate more effectively, create more compelling offers, and ultimately, build stronger connections with our audiences. For those looking to dive deeper, his website, kolenda.io, is an invaluable resource. [3][12]

Learn more:

Lessons from Nick Kolenda

On Persuasion and Influence

On Pricing Psychology

On Choice and Consumer Behavior

On Advertising and Marketing Communication

Written by Antoine Buteau

Lessons from Rick Hansen

Lessons from Eric Barker