Richard P. Rumelt, one of the most influential thinkers on strategy, has dedicated his career to cutting through the fluff and ambiguity that often plagues corporate planning. His work provides a rigorous framework for understanding what strategy is and, just as importantly, what it is not. Through his seminal books, "Good Strategy/Bad Strategy" and "The Crux," he has equipped leaders with the tools to create powerful, effective strategies.

On the Definition of Good Strategy

  1. "Good strategy is not just what you are trying to do. It is a cohesive response to a challenge." This foundational idea emphasizes that strategy is about problem-solving, not just goal-setting.
  2. "The core of strategy work is always the same: discovering the critical factors in a situation and designing a way of coordinating and focusing actions to deal with those factors."
  3. "A good strategy has an essential logical structure that I call the kernel." This kernel consists of three parts: a diagnosis, a guiding policy, and coherent actions.
  4. "Good strategy works by harnessing power and applying it where it will have the greatest effect."
  5. "Strategy is the craft of figuring out which contests are winnable and then focusing your resources to win them."
  6. "Strategy is not a checklist. It is a way of thinking, a way of approaching problems."
  7. "A good strategy honestly acknowledges the challenges being faced and provides an approach to overcoming them."
  8. "Good strategy requires choices, and choices mean saying no to some things in order to say yes to others."
  9. "The art of strategy is not just about what you do, but about what you don't do."

On the Kernel of a Good Strategy

  1. The Diagnosis: "A diagnosis defines or explains the nature of the challenge. A good diagnosis simplifies the often overwhelming complexity of reality by identifying certain aspects of the situation as critical."
  2. The Guiding Policy: "The guiding policy is an overall approach chosen to cope with or overcome the obstacles identified in the diagnosis. It is a pathway, not a set of detailed instructions."
  3. Coherent Actions: "Finally, coherent actions are feasible, coordinated policies, resource commitments, and moves undertaken to carry out the guiding policy. They are not just 'implementation'—they are the substance of the strategy."
  4. "The kernel does not spell out a long list of things to do. It is not a plan. A good strategy is a framework for guiding action."
  5. "Coherence is the secret sauce of a good strategy. The actions should be consistent and reinforce one another."

On the Hallmarks of Bad Strategy

  1. "Bad strategy is not simply the absence of good strategy. It is a specific pathology with identifiable symptoms."
  2. Fluff: "Fluff is a form of gibberish masquerading as strategic concepts or arguments. It uses 'Sunday words'—words that are abstract and sound important—to create the illusion of high-level thinking."
  3. Failure to Face the Challenge: "Bad strategy fails to recognize or define the challenge. If you fail to identify and analyze the obstacles, you don't have a strategy. Instead, you have a stretch goal or a budget."
  4. Mistaking Goals for Strategy: "Many bad strategies are just statements of desire rather than plans for overcoming obstacles. You cannot achieve a goal just by wanting it."
  5. Bad Strategic Objectives: "A strategic objective is set by a leader in order to deliberately focus the organization's attention. A bad objective is a 'dog's dinner' of everything everyone wants."
  6. "The first sign of a bad strategy is the profusion of buzzwords."
  7. "Bad strategy ignores the power and choices of others. It's a plan you could carry out in a closet."
  8. "Template-style strategic planning," where you just fill in the blanks for vision, mission, and values, "is the enemy of strategy."

On "The Crux" of the Problem

  1. "The crux of a strategic challenge is that one pivotal issue you can actually do something about—the one that, if solved, will unlock a cascade of positive outcomes." This is the central theme of his book, The Crux.
  2. "A strategist's job is not to fill out a form or to make a list of goals. It's to find the crux of the problem."
  3. "The crux is a combination of three things: It's a challenge, it's the critical point in the challenge, and it's a challenge you can do something about."
  4. "Finding the crux is a form of diagnosis, but it’s a more focused diagnosis. It’s not just what the problem is, but what the linchpin of the problem is."
  5. "Leaders who become strategists are those who learn to identify the crux and focus their organization's resources on it."
  6. "Don't just ask 'what should we do?' Ask 'what's the crux of the situation here?'"

On Competitive Advantage and Power

  1. "Competitive advantage is not about being the best at everything. It is about being different and having a set of activities that are difficult for rivals to imitate."
  2. "A good strategy creates or leverages a clear-cut advantage over rivals."
  3. "The most basic source of competitive advantage is focus—concentrating your resources on a narrow front."
  4. "Advantage is the asymmetrical distribution of power. A good strategy exploits an existing asymmetry or creates a new one."
  5. "Much of strategy is not about finding a brilliant new idea, but about exploiting the weaknesses of your competitors."
  6. "Change creates opportunity, and opportunity is where advantage is born."

On Leadership and the Role of the Strategist

  1. "The first job of a leader is to create a good strategy. It is a task of leadership, not a staff function."
  2. "A leader's most important responsibility is to identify the biggest challenges to forward progress and to devise a coherent approach to overcoming them."
  3. "Good strategy requires courage—the courage to make choices, to say no, and to concentrate resources."
  4. "A strategist is a designer. You are designing a coordinated set of actions."
  5. "The strategist must be a judge, weighing evidence and making difficult choices."
  6. "Having a strategy is not about being certain. It is about making a coherent bet."
  7. "A leader's job is to provide a guiding policy, not a detailed plan for every contingency."

On Thinking and Analysis

  1. "The truth is that most organizations don't have a strategy. They have a performance-oriented goal."
  2. "You can't do strategy by committee. It requires a single, integrating mind."
  3. "Analysis should be about understanding the structure of the situation, not just crunching numbers."
  4. "A lot of what people call 'strategy' is really just wishful thinking."
  5. "Hypotheses are the engine of strategic thinking. You must be willing to be wrong."
  6. "The state of 'not knowing' is a prelude to discovery."
  7. "Ask yourself: 'What is really going on here?' This simple question is the beginning of all good strategy."
  8. "Strategy is about how an organization will move forward. Saying that you will 'be the best' is not a strategy; it is a goal."
  9. "The essential difficulty in creating a good strategy is not logical; it is in the choice itself. The choice to focus, to concentrate, and to say no."

Sources and Further Reading: