Lessons from Vaclav Smil

Vaclav Smil, the Czech-Canadian scientist and policy analyst, has carved a unique niche as a "nerd's nerd," a data-driven realist whose work on energy, environment, food, and technological transitions has garnered a cult following, including luminaries like Bill Gates. His writings, spanning over 40 books, are a testament to his interdisciplinary approach and his insistence on confronting the material realities that underpin our modern world.

On Energy: The Universal Currency

Smil's work is grounded in the understanding that energy is the master resource, the fundamental currency of both natural systems and human civilizations.

Quotes:

"Energy is the only universal currency: one of its many forms must be transformed to another in order for stars to shine, planets to rotate, plants to grow, and civilizations to evolve." [1][2]
"Modern history can be seen as an unusually rapid sequence of transitions to new energy sources, and the modern world is the cumulative result of their conversions." [3]
"Our increasingly electrified, electronic, and data-driven society places steadily rising demand on reliable baseload power - that is, on electricity available 24/7/365." [4]
"The great hope for a quick and sweeping transition to renewable energy is wishful thinking." [4]
"Energy transitions take time and require societal and political will." [5]
"We must understand that energy is not just a commodity but the foundation of modern civilization." [5]
"Behind every morsel of bread, fruits, or meat is a large amount of transformed fossil fuels." [4]
"The history of energy use is a sequence of transitions to sources that are cheaper, cleaner, and more flexible." [4]
"We're a society that demands electricity 24/7." [4]
"Without the low operating costs, high efficiency, high reliability, and great durability of diesel engines, it would have been impossible to reach the extent of globalization that now defines the modern economy." [1]

Learnings:

Energy transitions are slow and complex. Smil consistently emphasizes that shifts from one primary energy source to another, like from wood to coal or coal to oil, have historically taken decades to unfold. [6] They are not merely technological substitutions but require vast infrastructural, economic, and social adjustments. [6]
Fossil fuels remain fundamental. Our civilization is built on the high energy density and reliability of fossil fuels, which are essential for producing the "four pillars of modern civilization": cement, steel, plastics, and ammonia. [7][8] A rapid move away from them is, in Smil's view, a logistical and economic fantasy. [3]
Renewables face significant hurdles. While acknowledging their importance, Smil is skeptical of the speed at which renewable energy sources like wind and solar can replace fossil fuels due to their intermittency, lower power density, and the massive material and land requirements for their infrastructure. [7][9]
Electricity is not the whole picture. A common mistake in energy discussions is to focus solely on electricity generation. Smil points out that this ignores the vast energy consumption in transportation, industry, and agriculture, sectors that are much harder to decarbonize. [10]
Energy and economic growth are inextricably linked. Smil's historical analysis shows a clear correlation between increased energy consumption and economic development. [11] He argues that for developing nations to achieve a higher standard of living, their energy use will inevitably increase. [12]

On Growth and Consumption: The Planetary Limits

A central theme in Smil's later work is the unsustainability of perpetual economic growth on a finite planet. He advocates for a more rational approach to consumption and a recognition of biophysical limits.

Quotes:

"Growth must end. Our economist friends don't seem to realise that." [13]
"The long-term survival of our civilization cannot be assured without setting limits on the planetary scale." [14]
"We know better, but we still worship high annual GDP growth rate, regardless of where it comes from." [3]
"We could halve our energy and material consumption and this would put us back around the level of the 1960s. We could cut down without losing anything important." [13]
"If everyone wants to eat like people in Bangladesh, then we would have food coming out of everybody's ears." [4]
"There is no reason we can't design a car to last for 35 years instead of six or seven." [4]
"The economists will tell you we can decouple growth from material consumption, but that is total nonsense." [13]
"Consuming 30, 40, 50 percent less of everything what we are consuming. Be it water, or steel, or energy, but we are not willing to go down that route." [14]
"Food waste, for instance, is just amazing. We grow all that stuff... and we waste 40 percent of everything they grow." [14]
"For individuals, this would mean a no less revolutionary delinking of social status from material consumption." [3]

Learnings:

Infinite growth on a finite planet is impossible. Smil argues that the core tenet of modern economics—continuous GDP growth—is on a collision course with the Earth's biophysical limits. [13]
Dematerialization is a myth. The idea that technology will allow us to decouple economic growth from material consumption is not supported by evidence. Smil points out that increased efficiency often leads to lower prices and thus higher overall consumption, a phenomenon known as Jevons paradox. [13]
Massive waste reduction is a low-hanging fruit. Smil frequently highlights the enormous inefficiencies in our current systems, particularly in food and energy. [14] Reducing this waste offers a significant opportunity to lessen our environmental impact without requiring radical new technologies. [14]
A shift in values is necessary. Ultimately, a sustainable future requires a move away from a culture of consumerism and the equation of well-being with material accumulation. [3]
The scale of the problem is immense. Smil consistently brings discussions back to the sheer scale of our global civilization and its material demands, arguing that solutions must be commensurate with this scale to be effective. [14]

On Environment and Climate Change: A Dose of Realism

Smil approaches environmental challenges, including climate change, with his characteristic data-driven pragmatism, often criticizing both alarmism and overly optimistic techno-fixes.

Quotes:

"No human civilization could ever sever our dependence on photosynthesis." [4]
"Harvesting the biosphere is still the most fundamental human activity. Without that, everybody's dead, really." [4]
"Meat is undoubtedly an environmentally expensive food." [4]
"Crises expose realities and strip away obfuscation and misdirection." [3]
"Despite decades of studies and climate summits, greenhouse gas emissions continue to soar." [15]
"We have ricocheted between catastrophism on one hand and the magical thinking of ‘techno-optimism’ on the other." [15]
"To believe that our understanding of these dynamic, multifactorial realities has reached the state of perfection is to mistake the science of global warming for the religion of climate change." [16]
"There are no swift, universal, affordable solutions to global environmental challenges." [17]
"Reduced meat consumption would be the single most important adjustment." [17]
"We cannot ignore the impacts of energy consumption on human health and well-being." [5]

Learnings:

The biosphere is the foundation of everything. Smil reminds us that our economies are subsystems of the biosphere, not the other way around. The health of our planet's ecosystems is non-negotiable for our survival. [13]
Climate change is a formidable challenge, but not the only one. While acknowledging the seriousness of climate change, Smil cautions against a singular focus that ignores other critical environmental issues like biodiversity loss, nitrogen cycle disruption, and water scarcity.
Techno-optimism is a dangerous delusion. Smil is highly critical of the belief that technological breakthroughs alone will solve our environmental problems. He emphasizes that innovation takes time to develop and scale, and that we cannot simply invent our way out of our predicaments. [4]
Pragmatic, incremental changes are our best bet. Instead of waiting for silver-bullet solutions, Smil advocates for the widespread implementation of existing, proven strategies, such as reducing food waste, eating less meat, and improving energy efficiency in buildings and transportation. [12][14]
Understanding numbers and scale is crucial. To grasp the magnitude of environmental challenges, one must appreciate the numbers involved—the tons of carbon emitted, the hectares of forest lost, the cubic meters of water consumed. Smil's work is a masterclass in this quantitative approach. [7][8]

On Knowledge and the Modern World: A Call for Humility

Smil is a critic of overspecialization and the detachment from the physical realities of life that he sees in modern society.

Quotes:

"Physics is indisputable, but economics rules." [3]
"I'm the product of the classical, old-fashioned European education that is broad-based. You want to get your degree in the world, you have to study all sorts of things." [4]
"I just don't stand for any nonsense." [4]
"Humanity never learns any lessons. Prescriptions don't matter. We already know exactly what to do. We just don't do it." [4]
"A realistic grasp of our past present and uncertain future is the best foundation for approaching the unknowable expanse of time." [8]

Vaclav Smil's work is a powerful antidote to the simplistic narratives and wishful thinking that often dominate public discourse. His relentless focus on the data and the material foundations of our world provides a necessary, if sometimes sobering, dose of reality. By understanding his key arguments, we are better equipped to navigate the complex challenges of the 21st century.

Learn more:

Lessons from Vaclav Smil

On Energy: The Universal Currency

On Growth and Consumption: The Planetary Limits

On Environment and Climate Change: A Dose of Realism

On Knowledge and the Modern World: A Call for Humility

Written by Antoine Buteau

Lessons from Maria Montessori

Lessons from Bill Campbell