Lessons from John Boyd

John Boyd, a maverick fighter pilot and influential military strategist, left behind a legacy of profound quotes and transformative ideas that extend far beyond the cockpit. His philosophies on strategy, leadership, and decision-making continue to resonate in the military, business, and various other competitive fields.

The "To Be or to Do" Philosophy

Boyd's "To Be or to Do" speech is a cornerstone of his leadership philosophy, urging individuals to choose between personal ambition and impactful action. [1][2]

"Tiger, one day you will come to a fork in the road, and you're going to have to make a decision about which direction you want to go... If you go that way you can be somebody. You will have to make compromises and you will have to turn your back on your friends. But you will be a member of the club and you will get promoted and you will get good assignments... Or you can go that way and you can do something—something for your country and for your Air Force and for yourself. If you decide you want to do something, you may not get promoted and you may not get the good assignments and you certainly will not be a favorite of your superiors. But you won't have to compromise yourself. You will be true to your friends and to yourself. And your work might make a difference. To be or to do? In life there is often a roll call. That's when you will have to make a decision. To be or to do? Which way will you go?" [2][3] This quote encapsulates the central dilemma Boyd presented to his protégés. [4]
"Would you rather be someone important, or would you rather do something important?" [1] This is a more concise version of his famous "To Be or to Do" challenge.
Leadership isn't about chasing promotions—it's about taking action that makes a difference. Boyd's philosophy emphasizes that a leader's legacy is defined by their impact and the people they inspire. [1]
True leadership is rooted in personal integrity. Boyd believed that genuine leaders prioritize the mission and the people they serve over personal accolades. [1]
Focus on the long game. Effective leaders, according to Boyd, don't chase quick victories but instead plan for a lasting, positive impact. [1]
Your legacy is defined by the teams you build and the people you help grow, not by personal achievements. [1]

The OODA Loop: Observe, Orient, Decide, Act

The OODA loop is Boyd's most famous contribution to strategic thought, a decision-making model applicable to any competitive environment. [5][6]

"Conflict can be viewed as repeated cycles of observing, orienting, deciding and acting by both sides, and also, I might add, at all levels." [7]
"In order to win, we should operate at a faster tempo or rhythm than our adversaries – or, better yet, get inside [the] adversary's Observation-Orientation-Decision-Action time cycle or loop." [8]
"Such activity will make us appear ambiguous and thereby generate confusion and disorder among our adversaries." [8]
The OODA loop is not just about speed, but about getting "inside" your opponent's decision cycle. This disrupts their rhythm and ability to react effectively. [5]
Orientation is the most critical phase of the loop. It's where you connect with reality, recognize your biases, and make sense of the situation. [9] Boyd referred to it as the schwerpunkt, a German term for "main emphasis." [9]
The OODA loop is an iterative process. It's a continuous cycle of feedback and adaptation, not a linear sequence. [10]
"Decisions without actions are pointless. Actions without decisions are reckless." [2][8]
The goal is to operate at a faster tempo to make the opponent's actions irrelevant. By cycling through the OODA loop more quickly, you can create a situation where the adversary is constantly reacting to outdated information. [11]
The OODA loop is a tool for dealing with uncertainty. It provides a framework for rational thinking in chaotic situations. [9][12]
Maneuver warfare is a psychological tool. The aim is to cause a "mental breakdown" in the enemy before they are physically destroyed. [11][13]

On Strategy and the Nature of Conflict

Boyd's views on strategy were revolutionary, emphasizing agility, adaptation, and psychological warfare.

"What is strategy? A mental tapestry of changing intentions for harmonizing and focusing our efforts as a basis for realizing some aim or purpose in an unfolding and often unforeseen world of many bewildering events and many contending interests." [9][14]
"People, ideas, hardware—in that order." [7] This highlights Boyd's belief in the primacy of human ingenuity and sound concepts over technology.
"You gotta challenge all assumptions. If you don't, what is doctrine on day one becomes dogma forever after." [2][15]
"The nature of war is to shape the enemy." [16]
"Fight the enemy, not the terrain." [8][17] This serves as a reminder to focus on the dynamic elements of a situation rather than static plans.
A strategy is not a rigid plan but a set of intentions that can adapt to a changing environment.
** [16]"If we don't communicate with the outside world–to gain information for knowledge and understanding–we die out to become a non-discerning and uninteresting part of that world."** [18]
Survival is equated with adaptation and openness. Isolation and a closed-off mindset lead to defeat. [19]
"The ability to shift and adapt more rapidly than the other... is what gave the F-16 the advantage." This learning from his work on the F-16 illustrates his broader philosophy of agility. [20]
"Compress own time and stretch out adversary time." This is a key guideline for gaining an advantage in conflict. [11]
Boyd rejected the idea that a fixed set of principles could govern warfare. He believed in using "appropriate bits and pieces" to adapt to the ever-changing environment of conflict. [11]

On Integrity and Freedom

Boyd's personal philosophy was as impactful as his strategic theories, emphasizing integrity, freedom, and a minimalist approach to life.

"If your boss demands loyalty, give him integrity. But if he demands integrity, then give him loyalty." [7][21]
"If a man asks me for my loyalty...I will give him my honesty. If a man asks me for my honesty...I will give him my loyalty!" [2]
"The most important thing in life is to be free to do things. There are only two ways to insure that freedom – you can be rich or you can you reduce your needs to zero." [2][15]

On Learning and Thinking

Boyd was a voracious learner who synthesized knowledge from a wide array of disciplines.

His approach was a "scheme of pulling things apart (analysis) and putting them back together (synthesis) in new combinations to find how apparently unrelated ideas and actions can be related to one another." [9][12]
He drew from diverse fields like quantum mechanics, cybernetics, and chaos theory to develop his ideas.
** [22]To truly understand Boyd's work, one must be open to non-linear thinking and continuous learning.**
** [23]He believed in understanding the "why" behind tactics, as a deeper understanding allows for the creation of new and advantageous combinations.**
** [20]"Ambiguity is central to Boyd's vision… not something to be feared but something that is a given… We never have complete and perfect information."** [8][22]

Key Learnings from John Boyd's Theories

Agility can overcome raw power. [6]
Tempo is about disrupting the opponent's rhythm, not just speed.**
** [5]Uncertainty is a weapon to be wielded against an adversary.**
** [8]Shared trust and understanding are the foundations of effective leadership, built through training and collaboration over time.**
** [24]Maneuver warfare is about "fighting smart" to generate the greatest decisive effect with the least cost.**
** [17][24]Avoid concentrating forces; instead, attack the enemy through multiple vectors at a high speed.**
** [17]The OODA loop has broad applications beyond the military, including in business, law, and education.**
** [6]Continuous improvement is driven by "unstructuring" old systems to allow for "creative induction" of new ideas.**
** [25]A key to success is the ability to change how we think.**
** [20]Effective decision-making requires being decisive, taking initiative, and maintaining autonomy.**
** [9][12]Boyd's Energy-Maneuverability Theory revolutionized aircraft design by focusing on the ability to shift between energy states rapidly.**
** [20][26]To gain an advantage, you must be able to create plans within an overall strategy, reinforcing what works and abandoning what doesn't.**
** [16]Boyd's work influenced the development of the U.S. Marine Corps' warfighting doctrine, emphasizing critical thinking over checklists.**
** [17][24]In a competitive environment, it's possible to win by being faster, even if you make initial mistakes, because you can correct your course before your opponent can react.**
** [27]Boyd's philosophy encourages a proactive and adaptive mindset, urging individuals and organizations to "get moving" rather than being paralyzed by analysis.** [27]

For those interested in a deeper dive into John Boyd's work, several books are highly recommended, including "Boyd: The Fighter Pilot Who Changed the Art of War" by Robert Coram, "Science, Strategy and War" by Frans P.B. Osinga, and "Certain to Win: The Strategy of John Boyd, Applied to Business" by Chet Richards. [28][29] A wealth of information, including Boyd's original briefings, can also be found at websites dedicated to his work, such as colonelboyd.com. [28][30]

Learn more: