Lessons from Paul Singer

Paul Singer, the founder of the formidable hedge fund Elliott Management, is a towering figure in the world of finance, known for his sharp intellect, disciplined investment strategies, and often-unapologetic activist campaigns. Over a career spanning more than four decades, Singer has cultivated a reputation as one of the most astute and successful money managers of his generation. His insights, often shared in rare interviews and detailed investor letters, offer a masterclass in risk management, distressed investing, and navigating the complexities of global markets.

On Risk Management and Humility

A cornerstone of Singer's philosophy is a relentless focus on risk management, born from early-career losses that instilled in him a deep respect for the market's unpredictability.

1. The Fundamental Question of a Survivor

Quote: "'What am I missing?' is a much more important question than 'How cool am I?'"
Learning: The most crucial trait for survival and success in investing is constant skepticism and humility. Overconfidence is a significant risk.
Source: Quoted in an article by Advisor Perspectives, April 16, 2019. [1]

2. The Illusion of Predictability

Quote: "It's difficult - and, I later came to conclude, impossible - to determine turning points."
Learning: Market timing is a fool's errand. A robust investment strategy should not depend on predicting market shifts.
Source: Quoted on Quoteswise, attributed to a 2013 statement. [2]

3. The Constant State of Vigilance

Quote: "You have to be in risk management mode all the time, not just when you might be particularly nervous, because it is impossible to time the transitions of markets to crisis conditions."
Learning: Risk management is not a reactive measure but a constant, proactive discipline.
Source: Quoted on Quoteswise, attributed to a 2013 statement. [3]

4. The Dangers of Complacency

Quote: "Coasting in money management does not turn out well."
Learning: Continuous effort, vigilance, and adaptation are necessary to succeed in the long term. Past success does not guarantee future returns.
Source: Quoted on Quoteswise, attributed to a 2013 statement. [2]

5. The Primary Goal: Capital Preservation

Learning: Singer's primary objective is capital preservation. While aiming for high returns, the first goal is not to lose money. This principle has been central to Elliott Management's longevity and success, with only two down years since its founding in 1977. [4]
Source: GuruFocus, "Investors Should Study Paul Singer's Approach to Investing," August 30, 2018. [1]

6. The Unpredictability of Market Psychology

Quote: "The recent trading environment has felt something like walking into a place and having a sense that something is wrong and dangerous but not knowing exactly what will happen or when."
Learning: Markets are driven by human psychology, which can be irrational and unpredictable. It's essential to be prepared for sudden shifts in sentiment.
Source: A-Z Quotes, referencing an unattributed quote. [5]

7. On Hedging

Quote: "I've never let my guard down by saying, 'I don't need to be hedged.'"
Learning: Maintaining hedges is a critical and continuous part of risk management, regardless of market conditions.
Source: BrainyQuote, unattributed. [6]

8. The Visceral Nature of Early Losses

Quote: "My introduction to risk and risk management… was personal and visceral, not academic."
Learning: Experiencing losses firsthand provides a much deeper and more lasting education in risk than any theoretical study.
Source: Quoted on Quoteswise, reflecting on his early career in 2013. [2]

On Investment Philosophy and Activism

Singer is a pioneer in activist investing, taking significant stakes in companies and pushing for changes to unlock shareholder value. His approach is often confrontational but rooted in deep analysis.

9. Creating Value, Not Just Identifying It

Quote: "We like to create value rather than merely identify it. If we just identify value, we can't make money unless the market moves the security in the predicted direction."
Learning: Proactive engagement to influence a company's direction can be a more reliable path to returns than passively waiting for the market to recognize value.
Source: Quoted on Quoteswise, attributed to a statement in February 2004. [2]

10. Controlling Your Own Destiny

Quote: "What we came to like very much about distressed investing is the opportunity to control one's destiny…"
Learning: Investing in distressed situations, where legal and financial processes can be influenced, offers a degree of control not present in traditional equity investing.
Source: Quoted on Quoteswise, attributed to a 2013 statement. [2]

11. The Flaw in the "Short-Term vs. Long-Term" Debate

Learning: Singer argues that the debate should not be about "short-term" versus "long-term" goals, but about "good ideas versus bad ideas." A good idea can create value quickly, while a bad long-term plan can destroy it.
Source: Equilar, "The Mind of An Activist Investor - Paul Singer," C-Suite Issue 31. [7]

12. The Role of the Activist

Quote: "Activist investing provides one possible answer [to who will do the work to create efficient markets]."
Learning: As passive investing grows, activists play a crucial role in holding corporate management accountable and ensuring markets remain efficient.
Source: Econlib, "In praise of investor activism," October 25, 2017. [8]

13. Defending Shareholder Rights

Quote: "If you don't defend your rights, what do you have?"
Learning: Shareholders have rights that should be vigorously defended to ensure accountability and protect their investment.
Source: Quoted on Quoteswise, attributed to a statement in January 2008. [2]

14. The Purpose of Shareholder Returns

Quote: "We're talking about people's pensions, their retirement plans, and the endowments that fund museums, hospitals and important charities. Every medium- to large-sized corporation has hundreds of millions of owners, and making a rate of return is a fundamental duty to all these people."
Learning: Generating returns for shareholders is not an abstract goal; it has a profound real-world impact on the financial well-being of millions.
Source: Equilar, "The Mind of An Activist Investor - Paul Singer," C-Suite Issue 31. [7]

15. The Fallacy of "Just Sell the Stock"

Quote: "The refrain 'if you don't like the management, just sell the stock' never made much sense to us anyway — why not use your rights as an owner to interact with management teams and try to effect changes?"
Learning: True ownership implies the right and responsibility to advocate for improvement, not just to exit when there are problems.
Source: The Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance, "Of Owners and Ownership," November 15, 2021. [9]

16. The Entrepreneurial Spirit in Hedge Funds

Quote: "Successful hedge funds will be entrepreneurial; it is the essence of the craft."
Learning: The ability to be innovative, proactive, and opportunity-driven is what distinguishes successful hedge funds.
Source: BrainyQuote, unattributed. [6]

On Markets, Economies, and Governments

Singer is a vocal critic of government and central bank policies that he believes distort markets and create systemic risks.

17. The Inherent Instability of the World

Quote: "Stability is not the way of the world."
Learning: Investors should not expect stable, predictable environments. Change and disruption are the norms.
Source: The Washington Post, "Meet the wealthy donor who's trying to get Republicans to support gay marriage," April 4, 2014, quoting a 2011 investor letter. [10]

18. The Dangers of Government Intervention

Quote: "It is a very bad idea for governments to create arbitrary and unfair outcomes, or outcomes resulting from the passions and whims of the government rather than from the law, just because they have the power to do so."
Learning: The rule of law, not arbitrary government power, is essential for a stable and fair economic system.
Source: A-Z Quotes, unattributed. [5]

19. The Perils of Monetary Easing

Quote: "QE Infinity” has so distorted the prices of stocks and bonds that nobody can possibly determine what the investing landscape would look like... in the absence of Fed bond-buying."
Learning: Unprecedented central bank interventions have made it impossible to gauge the true state of the economy and financial markets.
Source: A-Z Quotes, from a Business Insider article, "Billionaire Hedge Funder Paul Singer's 9-Point Plan To Save The Global Financial System," May 8, 2013. [5]

20. The Current Market Environment

Quote: "The state of stock markets today are just about as risky as I have ever seen."
Learning: Prolonged periods of low interest rates and government stimulus have created a highly leveraged and fragile market environment.
Source: Interview with Norges Bank Investment Management, February 2025. [11][12]

21. On Cryptocurrencies

Quote: "Tell me that something that is constructed as a computer program where you engage in some process of sitting there in front of your computer and after some period of time, and the expenditure of a bunch of electricity, a message appears on your screen that you've created something. It's ridiculous! It's nothing."
Learning: Singer views cryptocurrencies as having no intrinsic value, describing them as a "cult" and a marketing pitch.
Source: The Acquirer's Multiple, "Paul Singer: The Irrationality Of Markets And Investors," January 25, 2021, quoting an interview on the Grant Williams Podcast. [13]

22. The Enduring Value of Gold

Quote: "If you want an alternative currency, check out gold. It has stood the test of thousands of years as a store of value and medium of exchange."
Learning: In a world of currency debasement, gold remains the ultimate and most reliable form of real money.
Source: BrainyQuote, unattributed. [6]

23. On Sovereign Debt and Responsibility

Quote: "Imagine how much capital a country like Argentina might attract - if instead of defaulting seriatim and affecting a pose of anger toward creditors, it borrowed responsibly and honored its obligations."
Learning: Forcing sovereign debtors to pay is not just about collecting a debt, but about creating a world where responsible borrowing is rewarded with investment.
Source: The Washington Post, "Meet the wealthy donor who's trying to get Republicans to support gay marriage," April 4, 2014. [10]

24. The Flaw of "Too Big to Fail"

Learning: Singer has been a vocal critic of the "too big to fail" concept, arguing that the Dodd-Frank Act did not solve the problem but rather enshrined it, making the financial system potentially less stable.
Source: Hawai'i Public Radio, "SuperDonor Backs Romney — And Gay Marriage," April 17, 2012. [14]

25. The Dishonesty of Government Statistics

Quote: "The arithmetic of government statistics (jobs, growth and inflation) is distorted and dishonest almost beyond measure."
Learning: Investors should be highly skeptical of official government data, which may not reflect the true health of the economy.
Source: Quoted on Quoteswise, from a 2014 statement. [3]

26. On the Euro

Quote: "The bottom line is that the euro is a failed experiment."
Learning: A single currency without a unified fiscal and political structure is inherently flawed.
Source: A-Z Quotes, unattributed. [5]

27. On Artificial Intelligence Hype

Quote: "This AI is way over its skis in terms of practical value being brought to users... There are uses, and there will be additional uses, but it's way exaggerated."
Learning: Be wary of hype cycles, even with transformative technologies. The market's valuation can get far ahead of the actual, practical application.
Source: The Acquirer's Multiple, "Market Complacency: Paul Singer's Stark Warning for Investors," February 26, 2025. [15]

28. On the Fragility of Confidence

Quote: "Since the system is fundamentally unsound, all it would take is a loss of confidence to set off a collapse..."
Learning: In a fragile financial system, confidence is the glue holding it together, and it can evaporate with shocking speed.
Source: Reddit, "Elliott Management's Paul Singer just sent a chilling letter to clients. Thoughts??," April 30, 2014, quoting a client letter. [16]

On Mindset, Character, and Life

Singer's learnings extend beyond finance to the mindset required for success and his broader worldview.

29. Embracing Complexity

Quote: "You have got to welcome and embrace complexity."
Learning: The financial world is inherently complex. Those who can navigate and understand this complexity have an advantage.
Source: A-Z Quotes, unattributed. [5]

30. The Moral Superiority of Earning Money

Quote: "Resentment is not morally superior to earning money."
Learning: Singer dismisses criticism of wealth creation that stems from envy, arguing for the moral legitimacy of earning money through value creation.
Source: Conservative Transparency, quoting a Fortune profile. [2]

31. The Importance of Defending Liberty

Quote: "Individual liberty, the basic underpinning of American society, requires constant defense against the encroachment of the state."
Learning: A core part of his worldview is the belief in individual freedom and the need to be vigilant against government overreach.
Source: A-Z Quotes, unattributed. [5]

32. The Foundation of Community

Quote: "The building block of every community is family."
Learning: This quote reflects a core social belief in the importance of family structures for a healthy society.
Source: A-Z Quotes, unattributed. [5]

33. The Passion for the Puzzle

Quote: "I was passionate about investing. It was an obsessive hobby. I found it fun to study the relationships. It was interesting, like a game or a puzzle."
Learning: Deep passion and intellectual curiosity are powerful drivers of success in a demanding field like investment management.
Source: Quoted on Quoteswise, attributed to a 2013 statement. [2]

34. On Not Having Fun

Quote: "I don't think it's fun. I think skiing is fun... I keep doing it because... I think we do it well."
Learning: The motivation for his continued work is not about "fun" in the conventional sense, but about the pursuit of excellence and the satisfaction of performing a complex job well.
Source: Interview with Norges Bank Investment Management, February 2025. [17]

35. On Making the World a Better Place

Quote: "I do think we do make the world a better place... this style of investing... enhances the possibility and the probability that enterprises can service their customers. Competition is good."
Learning: He sees activist investing not just as a way to make money, but as a mechanism for improving corporate performance and fostering healthy competition, which ultimately benefits society.
Source: Interview with Norges Bank Investment Management, February 2025. [17]

36. Advice to Young People

Learning: Singer advises young people interested in business and finance to study history and political science to better understand systemic risks, and to avoid over-specialization in favor of broad knowledge.
Source: The Rio Times, "Hedge Fund Titan Paul Singer Warns: 'One of the Riskiest Times for Stocks'," February 27, 2025. [4]

37. The Irrationality of Humans

Quote: "I gave up a long time ago trying to base my investment management activities on the concept that markets and investors and traders are rational. Because people try to be rational. People think that they're rational. But quite frequently they're not."
Learning: A fundamental understanding of human psychology and its frequent irrationality is key to understanding market behavior.
Source: The Acquirer's Multiple, "Paul Singer: The Irrationality Of Markets And Investors," January 25, 2021, quoting an interview on the Grant Williams Podcast. [13]

38. The Importance of Character

Quote: "You have to have character. You have to be trustworthy. If you're trading with the street, you have to be straight."
Learning: Despite Wall Street's reputation, he believes high ethical standards and trustworthiness are essential for long-term success.
Source: Advisor Perspectives, "Behind Paul Singer's Fearsome Reputation," April 16, 2019. [1]

39. On the Opaque Nature of Big Banks

Quote: The “completely opaque” disclosures of major banks made it impossible to determine if they are risky or sound.
Learning: The complexity and lack of transparency in large financial institutions are a significant systemic risk.
Source: InsideSources, "Washington Refused to Break Up Big Banks, but Activist Investors May Force Changes," March 31, 2016. [18]

40. On Corporate Responsibility

Learning: Singer is a critic of the "stakeholder capitalism" model, arguing that it is "largely gibberish" and allows management to avoid accountability to the true owners of the company: the shareholders.
Source: The Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance, "Of Owners and Ownership," November 15, 2021. [9]

41. The Power of the Public Stampede

Quote: "The power of the public on a stampede is incalculable. There is no connection to value in many sectors of today's market."
Learning: Herd behavior can drive markets to extremes that are completely disconnected from fundamental value.
Source: Quoted on Quoteswise, from a 2001 statement on the dot-com boom. [2]

42. The Welcome Wagon of Opportunity

Quote: "The world has a rapidly shifting set of opportunities. You have to be there and you can't stay in too long. It's like the Welcome Wagon in front of your house for 10 minutes. You don't want to be too late and miss the cookies."
Learning: Investment opportunities are often fleeting. Agility and the readiness to act are critical.
Source: Quoted in the book "The New Investment Superstars" by Lois Peltz, as referenced by GuruFocus. [1]

43. The Assumption of Poor Management

Quote: "I'm almost always assuming or forcing myself to assume that the world is managed poorly…"
Learning: A default position of skepticism towards the competence of management (whether corporate or governmental) is a useful starting point for analysis.
Source: Quoted on Quoteswise, from a 2013 statement. [2]

44. The Wisdom of Experience

Quote: "In our lines of business, if someone is not burnt out or bored or fading in terms of capacity, the experience and wisdom is so, so needed... the layer of understanding beyond the spreadsheet."
Learning: In complex financial markets, accumulated experience and wisdom provide an analytical edge that quantitative analysis alone cannot replicate.
Source: Interview with Norges Bank Investment Management, February 2025. [17]

45. On Forcing the Issue

Learning: Singer's firm is known for its "unrelenting" and "bare-knuckled tactics" to force repayment from debtors, such as the 15-year battle with Argentina that included the temporary seizure of a naval vessel. This demonstrates a willingness to use every available legal tool to enforce contracts. [2][19]
Source: Conservative Transparency, "Paul Singer" and Institutional Investor, "The last hedge fund pit bull," June 9, 2017.

46. The Flaw in Zero Risk Weighting

Quote: "No security or instrument on the planet should have a zero risk weighting."
Learning: The regulatory practice of assigning zero risk to certain assets (like sovereign bonds) creates a false sense of security and is a fundamental flaw in the financial system.
Source: BrainyQuote, unattributed. [6]

47. On Derivatives

Learning: Singer believes derivatives trading should be standardized and moved to clearinghouses to reduce systemic risk. He has also stated that while he loves trading them, they have been a "net negative to society."
Source: A-Z Quotes & The Washington Post. [5][10]

48. The Rarity of True Bear Markets

Quote: "The starting point of my career in money management in 1973-74 was the time of the only true bear market any living non-Japanese investor has seen in major markets. Equities, real estate, you name it, everyone got run over."
Learning: Most modern investors have not experienced a truly devastating, prolonged bear market, which may contribute to their complacency.
Source: BrainyQuote, unattributed. [6]

49. The Importance of an Absolute Return Mindset

Learning: Elliott Management is an "absolute return fund," meaning the goal is to make money regardless of market direction, without being held to a specific benchmark. This reinforces the primary goal of capital preservation.
Source: Interview with Norges Bank Investment Management, February 2025. [17]

50. The Long-Term Insolvency of Developed Nations

Quote: "We believe the world's financial institutions are still essentially dependent on governments, but the Developed World governments themselves are hopelessly insolvent."
Learning: The true liabilities of developed nations, including unfunded entitlements, far exceed their assets, a fact that markets have yet to fully reckon with.
Source: Reddit, "Elliott Management's Paul Singer just sent a chilling letter to clients. Thoughts??," April 30, 2014, quoting a client letter. [16]

Learn more:

Lessons from Paul Singer

On Risk Management and Humility

On Investment Philosophy and Activism

On Markets, Economies, and Governments

On Mindset, Character, and Life

Written by Antoine Buteau

Lessons from Kyle Bass

Lessons from Mark Leonard