Lessons from Rita McGrath

A leading voice in strategy and innovation, Rita McGrath, a professor at Columbia Business School, has profoundly influenced modern business thinking. Her work challenges traditional notions of competitive advantage and provides a roadmap for navigating today's turbulent business environment.

On the End of Sustainable Competitive Advantage

The central theme of much of McGrath's work is the shift from long-term sustainable competitive advantage to a world of transient advantages.

"The era of sustainable competitive advantage is being replaced by an age of flexibility." [1]
"Exploiting a sustainable competitive advantage is great... If you can find it." [2]
"We used to think of the competitive environment as one of punctuated equilibrium, where there were long periods of stability between disruptions. Now the disruptions are coming closer and closer together." [1]
"In a transient-advantage context, unlike a conventional one, disengaging is not confused with business failure." [3]
"Without the assumption that an advantage will be long-lived, the urgency of an organization to move quickly increases." [3]
"Strategy today is really stuck. We're stuck in these old paradigms. We are using models from the 1960s that just don't apply anymore to the way the world works." [4]
"Your competition isn't just the company down the street any longer; it's companies from anywhere in the world." [1]
"Rather than trying to have changes all at once, you continually adjust your resources to your environment." [5]
"You have to be prepared to do it continually. And there are big implications for individuals and their careers." [5]
"The idea of learning from failure, the notion of studying business portfolios, and the concept of building new capabilities are all linked when you consider the new competitive environment and how companies need to to succeed within it." [1]

On Spotting Inflection Points

McGrath's book, "Seeing Around Corners," focuses on identifying and acting on strategic inflection points before they disrupt your business.

"A strategic inflection point is a change, typically in the environment, that could be caused by technology, social norms or many other different things. The key insight is that an inflection point causes the -taken for granted- assumptions on which your business is based on, to no longer be true." [4]
"Unfortunately, facts are often a lagging indicator of what could potentially be important. By the time you are dealing with a fact on the ground, whatever led to it has already happened." [6][7]
"The relationship between strategic degrees of freedom and signal strength is practically inverse." [6][7]
"In the unfair way in which life operates, the moment at which you have the richest, most trustworthy information is often the moment at which you have the least power to change the story told by that information." [6][7]
"Snow melts from the edges. You have to get out to the edges of your organization to see what's really going on." [8]
"Inflection points happen when companies see the problems or signals bubbling up and simmering before it boils over. These events are irreversible and if not acted upon, it gives other companies an open invitation for dominance." [9]
"If you cling to your old model, you view change as a problem. But if you embrace an inflection point, and view things positively, you're in a position to benefit from the potential opportunity." [10]
"These things don't happen overnight, they feel as though they do when they finally make themselves known, but usually they've been brewing for a long-long time before they show up on your doorstep fully formed." [11]
"The very concept of “industry” is an artificial categorization. Often the most important competition any business will face is from entrants who are not hamstrung by assumptions about what their “industry” expects of them."
" [6][7]What are the early warnings and leading indicators we could look at..." [12]

On Innovation and Growth

McGrath advocates for a continuous and disciplined approach to innovation.

"Consistent, ongoing innovation and extraordinary closeness to customers is the only possible response." [13]
"With discovery-driven growth (DDG), you invest small amounts of money—money you can afford to lose—to get the information that you need so that you can invest more confidently." [3]
"The goal is to convert assumptions to knowledge as quickly and cheaply as possible." [13]
"And of course, customers are notorious for being unable to articulate a need until they are shown how it can be met." [3][13]
"You can't actually pick the winners. So you need to seed many ideas..." [14]
"Every dollar and every hour of operations capacity allocated disproportionately to entrepreneurial initiatives is money and time denied the existing business." [3]
"Innovation used to be over there, and strategy was over here, but now they are inseparable." [1]
"Innovation requires a little slack." [15]
"The discovery-driven approach allows making early significant changes and avoiding blind big leaps towards innovation." [9]
"You can't plan for an uncertain future the way you can plan if you're basing your ideas on a strong platform of previous experience." [11]

On Leadership and Organizational Culture

Effective leadership and a supportive culture are critical for thriving in a transient-advantage world.

"You can't manage a secret. if we can get that on the table. and we can understand where the problems are we have enough talent and intelligence to figure it out but if we don't know the problems are there if we're not attuned to the early warnings that things could be shifting we're going to miss it." [16]
"The most important behavior on your part involves dedicating a disproportionate share of your own time, attention, and discretionary resources to creating new business models." [3]
"The better CEOs... are institutionalizing practices that make sure they don't get out of touch and make sure they don't go into defensiveness. It becomes a culture of curiosity, a culture of 'let's really understand what's going on out there.'" [14]
"Overconfidence ranks high among the biggest mistakes leaders make." [17]
"Leaders use their pivotal position as a point of convening as much data as they can. They listen very intently. They need to create a safe space, a context in which people can bring them information that's difficult to hear." [17]
"Making sure that as you're making decisions, that you want to encourage, you want to obligate diversity of perspectives' is key." [14]
"Level-skipping conversations are a tool that Dr. McGrath recommends to help leaders guard against becoming too insular." [18]
"So even in firms that embrace change and appear to manage it well, there are elements of tremendous stability in their businesses." [3]
"You're going to be very careful about having your organizational system settle down too much, because too much stability can be dangerous." [1]
"Finally, you must be prepared for your organization's top talent to work on entrepreneurial initiatives. This can create a painful dilemma." [3]

On Mindset and Strategy Execution

McGrath emphasizes the importance of an agile and curious mindset in strategy.

"Inherently, companies like ours are super agile, because we are not in control of our own destiny … We can only live off something that our clients have decided to do." [3][13]
"Trying to do more than the firm is capable of handling is tantamount to doing nothing." [3]
"When the ratio of assumptions you have to make relative to knowledge that you possess is high—a different set of disciplines needs to be employed." [3]
"The techniques described here are not about making predictions and being right. They're about generating..." [15]
"We must not try to become large in order to become powerful. We must become powerful in order to become large." [3]
"It is all too common for companies to rush through this phase, curtailing the valuable learning of what the ultimate product or service might look like." [13]
"Framing your business in the interaction field opens companies to many opportunities when it positions itself within the network of the ecosystem and not within the constraints of its specialized category." [9]
"If each attempt cost me a dime, I can attempt many things. If each one cost me $1 billion, I'm going to have to be a lot more careful." [19]
"You need to build in practices for healthy disengagement which is to be able to recognize the erosion of a competitive advantage and to move resources out of those situations." [5]

Learn more:

Lessons from Rita McGrath

On the End of Sustainable Competitive Advantage

On Spotting Inflection Points

On Innovation and Growth

On Leadership and Organizational Culture

On Mindset and Strategy Execution

Written by Antoine Buteau

Lessons from Amy Webb

Lessons from Michael Bungay Stanier