
Lessons from Max Mullen
Max Mullen co-founded Instacart. He also invests in early-stage companies and runs Workshop, a founder community in San Francisco. — Max Mullen’s Website.
Part 1: Defining the "Builder" Mindset
- Look for where founders spend their energy: Mullen uses scuffed sneakers as a playful example of what focus on a company can look like. He treats the shoes as a possible clue and says changing them will not make anyone a better founder. — Dirty White Sneakers.
- Find founders who make others want to build their version of the future: Mullen looks for founders whose enthusiasm for what could exist is strong enough to attract talented people to work on it. — Max Mullen on Uncapped.
- Expect a contrarian idea to look wrong for a while: Mullen says a founder pursuing an unfamiliar consumer behavior may need to tolerate looking mistaken for years while continuing to test and build. — Max Mullen on Uncapped.
- Give each early risk the attention it deserves: Mullen recalls that Instacart had many unanswered questions at the outset. Dwelling on every possible failure before testing the service might have kept the team from starting. — Building a Customer-Focused Grocery Delivery Startup.
- Plan for the work behind the consumer app: Mullen describes Instacart as an unusually complex marketplace. Alongside the shopping app, the team had to build software for shoppers and retailers and a system for routing and batching orders. — Max Mullen on Uncapped.
Part 2: Architecting Company Culture
- Define culture through shared beliefs and behavior: Mullen describes culture as the beliefs, habits and norms that shape how people work. A mission and a set of values can express those beliefs. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- Write down values while the team is still small: Mullen suggests around 20 employees as a good time to codify values. He recommends looking at how early employees work and asking the team to weigh in on the draft. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- Write down values the team already uses: Mullen recommends looking at what the founders and early employees actually believe and deciding which of those beliefs should be written down as company values. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- Use language people would actually say in a meeting: Mullen says values should be short and sound like language employees use when making decisions. At Instacart, the value about making every minute count could guide a team toward a smaller release it could ship sooner. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- Make introducing the values a moment the team will remember: Mullen suggests setting aside time at an offsite or an all-hands to explain the values and help the team remember how they came about. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- Refresh values when people struggle to use them: Instacart’s first eight values were hard to remember. Mullen says he listens for confusion in onboarding and asks employees whether the values help them make decisions. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
Part 3: Operationalizing Core Values
- Use the values when deciding whom to hire: Mullen recommends putting written values to work in hiring, company goals and the behavior leaders recognize. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- Look at where your values show up in practice: Mullen identifies four ways to put culture into practice: how the company hires, what it aims for, what it rewards and the environment it creates. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- Recognize people for specific examples of a value: Instacart employees could send a colleague a thank-you note tagged with the value the colleague had demonstrated. The notes were shared internally. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- Design the workspace to reinforce how people work: Mullen says Instacart used shared rooms and soft seating to keep some of the informal feel of the house where the early team worked. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- Improve the customer experience by accounting for everyone who shapes it: Mullen says Instacart changed a customer-focus value to reflect how the experience also depends on shoppers, retailers and advertisers. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- Use urgency to choose a smaller scope: Mullen gives the example of choosing a two-day version of a project over a two-week version when shipping sooner matters. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- Assess ownership directly: Mullen suggests making ownership a distinct part of the interview when it is one of the company’s values. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- Grow the pie for all sides of the marketplace: Instacart describes “Grow the Pie” as creating value for retailers, customers, brands and shoppers, since the company depends on each group’s success. — Fidji Simo’s Letter on Instacart’s IPO.
- Listen to how employees explain teamwork in their own words: Mullen says hearing employees describe Instacart as both hard-working and kind gave him better language for explaining its Go Far Together value. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
Part 4: Early-Stage Hustle and Execution
- Let families shop from stores they already trust: Mullen says Instacart found stronger fit with families after it added retailers and their full catalogs. Customers wanted delivery from the stores where they already liked to shop. — Max Mullen on Uncapped.
- Find a way to serve customers while partnerships are still out of reach: Mullen says Instacart started by building relationships with local store managers. The team later formed formal partnerships, starting with smaller grocers that could try something new more quickly. — Building a Customer-Focused Grocery Delivery Startup.
- Have founders answer early support calls: Mullen says Instacart’s three founders took turns answering customer calls on their cell phones. They fixed the immediate issue and asked what else the service could do better. — Building a Customer-Focused Grocery Delivery Startup.
- Build enough of the catalog to test whether customers want it: Mullen recalls that Instacart could not get product photos from Trader Joe’s. With the store manager’s agreement, the team bought one of each product so it could create a catalog and test demand. — Max Mullen on Uncapped.
- Demonstrate the product to earn a meeting: Apoorva Mehta recalled sending Y Combinator partner Garry Tan a six-pack through Instacart after missing the application deadline. Tan invited him to meet the partners the next day. — Apoorva Mehta on Instacart’s Early Break.
- Build the capacity to move quickly: Mullen argues that a consumer startup with an unconventional idea should be ready to build and ship quickly once the opportunity becomes obvious and competitors appear. — Uncapped with Max Mullen.
- Explain what is different about your approach: Mullen recalls investors rejecting grocery delivery because businesses such as Webvan had failed. The investors who backed Instacart saw a large market and a different way to serve it. — Building a Customer-Focused Grocery Delivery Startup.
- Look for new demand when a competitive shock hits: Amazon’s purchase of Whole Foods put a major Instacart relationship at risk. Mullen says it also prompted other grocers to rethink their online plans, giving Instacart a reason to reopen partnership conversations. — Max Mullen on Uncapped.
Part 5: Customer Empathy and Proximity
- Try doing the work your product is meant to support: Mullen says he still occasionally fulfills Instacart orders. The experience shows how hard it is to infer what another shopper would accept as a substitute. — Max Mullen on Uncapped.
- Measure the parts of delivery quality that customers notice: Mullen recalls tracking late deliveries, orders per week and the share of items shoppers found. The team used weekly software changes to improve those measures. — Max Mullen on Uncapped.
- Find out how people experience a problem you haven’t lived: Mullen says founders selling to businesses need insight that comes from working in the industry, knowing its customers or facing the problem themselves. — Max Mullen on Uncapped.
- Start with a problem customers already want solved: Mullen looks for problems customers have already tried to fix and would pay to solve. He recalls that grocery shopping was already a recurring chore before Instacart existed. — The Four Deadly Startup Sins.
- Turn repeated customer requests into a product test: Mullen recalls customers asking for a website so they could search for groceries with a keyboard and monitor. His co-founder built a first version over a weekend, and it quickly became Instacart’s most-used platform at the time. — Building a Customer-Focused Grocery Delivery Startup.
Part 6: Running Effective Product Brainstorms
- Help the team surface its best ideas: Mullen says that as a product team grows, its leader should spend more time drawing out promising ideas from others and helping those ideas reach the roadmap. — How to Run a Product Brainstorm.
- Set themes and ask for ideas in advance: Mullen starts with the customer problems the team wants to solve or the metrics it wants to improve. He asks participants to prepare ideas around those themes before the session. — How to Run a Product Brainstorm.
- Bring the current product into the room: Before brainstorming changes to an existing product, Mullen suggests having the team use it again and bringing screenshots of the current flows and comparable products. — How to Run a Product Brainstorm.
- Agree in advance on how ideas will be judged: Mullen recommends telling the team whether it will choose ideas for their likely impact, their small scope, or a combination of both. — How to Run a Product Brainstorm.
- Give unfinished ideas room to develop: Mullen sets aside critique and scope questions during idea generation so people can share rough ideas and build on one another’s suggestions. — How to Run a Product Brainstorm.
- Write ideas alone before discussing them as a group: Mullen asks people to write their ideas first and then present them aloud. He suggests breaking a large group into smaller groups so everyone has time to speak. — How to Run a Product Brainstorm.
- Show the team how its ideas will be prioritized: Mullen groups similar ideas and brings the shorter list back to the team for feedback. He makes clear that some ideas will have to stay off the roadmap. — How to Run a Product Brainstorm.
Part 7: Hiring and Interviewing Standards
- Ask candidates how they would improve the product: When interviewing for customer-facing roles, Mullen asks candidates who have used the product what they think of it and what changes would help customers. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- Look for evidence that candidates sought other perspectives: Mullen describes a strong candidate answer that draws on how friends, roommates or family members actually use the product and suggests improvements for those users. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
- See how candidates work on a problem the team has faced: Mullen describes asking candidates to solve a real problem and present their reasoning so the team can see how they think, communicate and work. — Max Mullen on Company Values and Culture.
Part 8: Angel Investing and Assessing Founders
- Check what has to line up inside the buyer: Mullen says an acquisition needs a strategic reason for the buyer, resources to do the deal and a senior person willing to champion it internally. — Founders in Arms with Max Mullen.
- Use partnerships to learn how a buyer might work with you: Mullen recalls that Caper approached him for help getting an introduction to Instacart as a potential partner. He invested, and Instacart later acquired the company. — Founders in Arms with Max Mullen.
- Choose investors for the help they can provide: Mullen advises founders to consider how an investor can help, what signal the investor sends and how much capital they can provide. He recommends checking references with founders the investor has backed. — How to Choose Investors.
- Imagine professionals coordinating multiple AI agents: Mullen speculates that professionals could direct several specialized agents, with managers supplying resources and authority to the system. He presents this as a possible way to organize work. — Super Agents.