David Reich is a professor of genetics at Harvard Medical School who studies ancient DNA. This collection gathers his own words from podcast conversations. — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich on Genetics and Ancient Humanity.

Visual summary of operating lessons from David Reich.

Part 1: The Biology of Human Evolution and Natural Selection

  1. On little directional selection: David Reich: "So one question is— there’s an increasing view amongst geneticists that natural selection is a process where there’s relatively little directional selection to adapt to new environments." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  2. On metabolism and immune traits: David Reich: "So it’s very clear that there is an extreme overrepresentation of change on variants that affect metabolism and immune traits." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  3. On selection pushing in one direction: David Reich: "So that genetic combination in West Eurasia has been pushed down again and again over the last 10,000 years under the pressure of natural selection without a doubt in its action on many, many independent genetic variants all pushing in the same direction in an overwhelmingly statistically significant way." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  4. On changes in frequency: David Reich: "So if that was a common process in evolution, we would expect many genetic changes to be 100% different in frequency between Europeans and East Asians or West Africans and Europeans." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  5. On selection quickening: David Reich: "But maybe over a shorter period of time, selection has quickened, and variants have started rising in frequency in the last maybe few hundred generations or something like that, and we might be able to appreciate that." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  6. On feast and famine: David Reich: "So one possible interpretation of this, and this is speculative, is that you’re shifting from a mode of survival that’s more feast and famine to one where food is more regular and it’s not as advantageous to store fat." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).

Part 2: Ancient DNA Lab Methodology and Preservation

  1. On getting DNA out more efficiently: David Reich: "I think it's all of those things, but it's technically driven as many of these things are, and we're probably getting DNA out with maybe eight or nine orders of magnitude more efficiency than we were 13 years ago." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  2. On new samples being exciting: David Reich: "Every new sample from a previously unexcavated archeological context has been incredibly exciting." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  3. On suspecting contamination: David Reich: "We thought maybe this is an artifact of our dirty data of various problems with our data that might occur contamination which had afflicted our field." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  4. On reconstructions versus real DNA: David Reich: "And so the reconstructions one makes from populations living today are often quite different from the reconstructions you make when you actually looked at DNA from known times and places, and that's telling you that people have moved around too much, such that the present day diversity around the world has obscured what was there before." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  5. On a single statistical instantiation: David Reich: "Important, but it's limited in terms of its statistical information it provides about the past, 'cause it's only a single statistical instantiation of the evolutionary process recorded in mitochondrial DNA." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  6. On fragmented DNA: David Reich: "The DNA is naturally fragmented by the degradation process into fragments that are rarely more than 70 or 60 bases long, and the typical length that we get from sequencing is maybe 30 or 40 or 50 bases." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  7. On old DNA from all over Africa: David Reich: "So we need DNA, old DNA from 50,000 years ago, 100,000 years ago, 200,000 years ago from all over Africa because it’s super clear that our lineage is complicated within Africa." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).

Part 3: Interbreeding and Adaptive Introgression

  1. On people we didn’t expect: David Reich: "We find Denisovans, we find people we completely didn’t expect to see before that break our understanding of the past." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  2. On gene flow between modern humans: David Reich: "Although there is gene flow between all groups of modern humans, at least at low levels, going to 100,000 years." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  3. On Neanderthals meeting modern humans: David Reich: "So these humans occupied Western Eurasia, and we know they encountered modern humans as modern humans expanded out of Africa and the Near East." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  4. On persistent Neanderthal exchange: David Reich: "And we can't currently rule out some persistent Neanderthal exchange, but it's a much, much lower level, if at all." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  5. On the standard model of divergence: David Reich: "So just to give you an example of this, the standard model is basically this: that modern humans separated from a group that is ancestral to Denisovans and Neanderthals, these two groups for which we have sequences, somewhere between maybe 500,000 to 750,000 years ago." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  6. On deep substructure: David Reich: "But it’s very clear that you can’t explain, for example, modern African DNA without invoking very extreme substructure as deep as the mixtures that produced Neanderthal— contributed and mixed between Neanderthals and modern humans." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  7. On ghost populations: David Reich: "That's what we call a ghost population, a population we reconstruct statistically from groups living today, but we don't have samples from today, and what we find again and again with DNA is we predict these populations and then we see them once we obtain DNA from the right time in place." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).

Part 4: Population Turnover and Migration

  1. On mixture and migration: David Reich: "But what I’m going to tell you about is how we came to be, how we are from another perspective through mixture and migration." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  2. On the Yamnaya expansion: David Reich: "Prior to this time, there were many diverse archeological cultures making different types of ceramics and pots, but after the Yamnaya expand, there's a monoculture and homogeneity across a vast region, all the way from central Europe, Hungary, all the way to Mongolia, as these people expand very rapidly." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  3. On the record of European history: David Reich: "And what we now have is many, many thousands of whole genome datasets published, and many, many more unpublished more than we have published, that provide a nearly gap-less record of European population history in space and time over the last 10,000 years with a more gap-y record between about 50,000 and 10,000 years." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  4. On a male-biased process: David Reich: "And we think the most likely explanation for what’s happening now is that it actually is a male-biased process, but it’s one that’s interrupted." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  5. On not confusing it with an invasion: David Reich: "And the DNA from these people spreads from all of these places, and so I think that many archaeologists would tell you, 'Do not confuse this with an invasion,' and they'd be right to emphasize that." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  6. On the history of Britain: David Reich: "It's a case of paper where we were writing a paper on the history of Britain in the last few thousand years, and we were reporting data from 793 individuals in one paper." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  7. On Colombia’s Y chromosomes: David Reich: "Maybe it’s not what happened 4,000 years later amongst the descendants of the Iberians in the Americas where today in Colombia, 95% of the Y chromosomes are European, 95% of the mitochondrial DNAs are Native American." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).

Part 5: Race, Culture, and Genetic Determinism

  1. On recurrent mixture: David Reich: "I think that the sort of lesson from ancient DNA and the genome revolution has been that anyone in the world is the result of recurrent mixture again and again in the past." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  2. On differences within a population: David Reich: "But on average, the amount of genetic difference between two individuals or two genomes within a population is six times greater than the average across two populations." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  3. On the Nazis and the Aryans: David Reich: "And that was used by, for example, the Nazis to argue that these were spreads of Aryans moving across the landscape and being very disruptive and violent, for example." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  4. On superiority and inferiority: David Reich: "I think it’s not a triumphal march of superiority and inferiority with the group that now comes in having advantages somehow establishing itself permanently." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  5. On census categories in the past: David Reich: "And if you were to assign census categories in the past, they would have broken down along completely different fault lines from the way you break them down today." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  6. On variation among Europeans: David Reich: "There are substantial variation amongst Europeans, and more broadly, Western Eurasians, or people who are called Caucasians or white on the US census." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  7. On being interested in your own history: David Reich: "But it’s very, very tempting to be interested in your own history and think it’s important." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  8. On archaeologists and large-scale migration: David Reich: "And so the DNA results were extremely disruptive to people in archaeology who had made these arguments that large-scale migration, large-scale disruption probably didn’t occur in the past." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).

Part 6: Measuring Selection Through Time

  1. On watching frequencies shift together: David Reich: "And so you can actually watch all these little variables, all these little gene frequencies, tens of millions of them shifting up and down in coordination." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  2. On agriculture and the genome: David Reich: "And you might expect that in reaction to a change so economically, dietarily, cognitively transformative as agriculture, the genome might shift in terms of how it adapts." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  3. On living more densely: David Reich: "There’s agriculture, there’s people living more densely, there’s infectious disease happening in a different way, in a different type than before." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  4. On selection against body fat: David Reich: "So one example of this is that there’s a very clear downward selection against body fat and against predisposition to high body mass index, predisposition to what today manifests itself as type 2 diabetes." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).

Part 7: Industrializing Ancient-DNA Science

  1. On learning the new history: David Reich: "I get to be part of trying to learn about the new history — about the history of South Asia." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  2. On the growth in genomes: David Reich: "And so, for example, in 2009, it was zero, and in 2010, it was five, and maybe in 2014, it was maybe 40 or so, and now it's well over 7,000." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  3. On thirsty archaeologists: David Reich: "True archaeologists who are truly dedicated to understanding the past are super thirsty for knowledge about the time periods." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).

Part 8: Scientific Judgment and Model Change

  1. On a big shock: David Reich: "So the example that you mentioned is something that’s been a big shock from the ancient DNA revolution." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  2. On being skeptical of a signal: David Reich: "And when we looked at the data, we saw such a signal, and we were actually quite incredulous at that signal because I certainly came from a background which thought there was no such signal, and so I was very skeptical." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  3. On people's views of the past: David Reich: "I think sometimes people are dug into particular views of the past that are challenged by the new findings that come from scientific research such as ancient DNA." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  4. On epicycles: David Reich: "And people have evoked epicycles, for example, natural selection for the mitochondrial DNA coming from modern humans, or natural selection coming from the Y chromosome coming from modern humans somehow being more advantageous and pushed up in frequency.But that would have to really happen on both these parts of the genome to produce this pattern." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).

Part 9: Language, Migration, and Cultural Identity

  1. On Indo-European languages: David Reich: "Indo-European languages are an amazing instance, but by no means the only instance of amazing language spreads." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  2. On two language groups in India: David Reich: "There are exceptions to this, but most people fall in this category, and they follow the two major language groups in India, Dravidian and Indo-European." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  3. On a gradient of ancestry: David Reich: "So today in South Asia, almost everybody is on a gradient of ancestry with two poles, what we call the ancestral North Indians and the ancestral South Indians, with very few exceptions." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  4. On steppe ancestry pulsing into India: David Reich: "But we can tell that that steppe ancestry pulsed into India between 4000 and 3500 years ago by comparison to diverse genetic data we have from Central Asians and people from the northern parts of South Asia." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).

Part 11: Variation Behind the Global Pattern

  1. On rare mixing keeping diversity: David Reich: "What’s actually happening is occasionally these groups merge together and recharge their diversity so that the diversity is maintained in the ensemble of rarely mixing groups." — Dwarkesh Podcast: David Reich (Singju Post transcript, his turns).
  2. On northern Europe: David Reich: "It was not known how this impacted the populations of places that had been previously and continued to be densely settled, like Europe, but we now know from the genetic data that this was a massive impact, so in Northern Europe, more than half the ancestry of many northern parts of Europe today descends from this expansion." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).
  3. On sex bias: David Reich: "And so we have that tool available to us too, to understand the process of sex bias and mixture processes of different populations." — Sean Carroll's Mindscape 179: David Reich (his turns).