Joel Mokyr is an economic historian at Northwestern University whose research examines technological change and the origins of modern economic growth. — Northwestern Faculty Profile.

Infographic for "Lessons from Joel Mokyr".

On the Nature of Economic Growth

  1. Collective knowledge: Mokyr argues that economies grow partly by increasing their collective knowledge of nature and applying it productively; that knowledge does not emerge automatically. — A Culture of Growth.
  2. Useful knowledge: Mokyr distinguishes trade-driven growth from sustained growth driven by useful knowledge of natural phenomena and techniques. — How Did We Get So Rich?.
  3. The skilled minority: In Mokyr's account, a comparatively small group of skilled people initiates much technological progress, including mechanics, engineers and applied mathematicians. — The Future Economy.
  4. Mechanics and engineers: Mokyr includes practitioners as well as intellectuals among the people whose skills helped drive early modern innovation. — The Future Economy.
  5. Attitude and aptitude: Mokyr identifies cultural willingness to investigate nature and technical ability to act on discoveries as complementary drivers of technological progress. — A Culture of Growth.
  6. Institutions also matter: Attitude and aptitude alone are not enough: Mokyr also emphasizes institutions that reward inquiry and help useful knowledge spread. — The Market for Ideas.
  7. Knowledge and diminishing returns: Mokyr sees no obvious historical sign that useful knowledge faces the diminishing returns that can limit other growth mechanisms. — How Did We Get So Rich?.
  8. Trade and knowledge: Trade and specialization can raise output, but Mokyr argues that expanding useful knowledge created a more sustained growth mechanism after the Industrial Revolution. — How Did We Get So Rich?.
  9. Question inherited authority: Mokyr describes how deference to earlier authorities could constrain inquiry, and how early-modern thinkers increasingly challenged that deference. — The Market for Ideas.
  10. Make novelty viable: Questioning inherited wisdom mattered because institutions also began to reward and protect new observations and ideas. — The Market for Ideas.
  11. Progress is fragile: Mokyr compares technological progress to a fragile plant: favorable conditions are necessary, and the historical flourishing of innovation was contingent. — The Lever of Riches.
  12. Support innovation: Technological progress is not automatic; Mokyr argues it needs social and economic conditions in which new ideas can survive and spread. — The Lever of Riches.
  13. Growth was historically slow: Mokyr says long-term increases in living standards before industrialization were much slower than the sustained gains that followed. — The Future Economy.
  14. Sustained growth is unusual: The long run of economic growth since the Industrial Revolution is historically exceptional in Mokyr's account. — The Future Economy.
  15. Culture and enrichment: Mokyr argues that changes in beliefs, values and preferences helped create the conditions for Europe's Great Enrichment. — A Culture of Growth.
  16. The educated elite: In Mokyr's account, changed attitudes among European intellectuals helped make useful knowledge and technological change more legitimate. — A Culture of Growth.

On Technology and Innovation

  1. The fragile plant: Mokyr compares technological progress to a fragile plant whose flourishing depends on favorable surroundings and may be short-lived. — The Lever of Riches.
  2. Favorable conditions: Innovation is not automatic: Mokyr's history shows that a supportive social environment helps new techniques endure and diffuse. — The Lever of Riches.
  3. Challenge a constraint: Mokyr describes technological change as an individual challenge to a constraint that others treat as given. — The Lever of Riches.
  4. Question assumed limits: One route to invention is to challenge a technical constraint that existing practice takes for granted. — The Lever of Riches.
  5. Technology and nature: Mokyr places human interaction with the physical environment at technology's core, while acknowledging that social relations determine how techniques spread. — A Culture of Growth.
  6. Harness natural regularities: For Mokyr, technical knowledge helps people understand and use regularities in nature to meet material needs. — A Culture of Growth.
  7. Artisan competence: Mokyr credits Britain's skilled artisans, instrument makers and engineers as important contributors to early industrialization. — The Market for Ideas.
  8. Skill and science together: Practical artisans helped make early machinery work, while formal codified knowledge became increasingly important for sustained later progress. — The Market for Ideas.
  9. Make ideas workable: The Industrial Revolution depended in part on skilled mechanics and machine tools that could turn designs into reliable equipment. — The Market for Ideas.
  10. Tools make ideas real: Mokyr emphasizes the dexterous practical work needed to turn theoretical insights into functioning technology. — The Market for Ideas.
  11. The limit of tinkering: Mokyr argues that artisanal tinkering alone would eventually face diminishing returns without insights from formal theoretical or experimental knowledge. — The Past and the Future of Innovation.
  12. Connect practice and theory: Sustained technical progress requires practical invention to draw on and contribute to a growing body of formal knowledge. — The Past and the Future of Innovation.
  13. Two kinds of knowledge: Mokyr distinguishes knowledge of how to make things work from knowledge of the natural principles that explain why they work. — The Market for Ideas.
  14. Bridge knowing and making: Mokyr argues that exchanges between theorists and artisans helped connect explanations of nature to useful techniques. — The Market for Ideas.
  15. Understand why: In Mokyr's steel example, understanding why a process works makes it easier to improve and adapt it. — Social Science Bites Interview.
  16. Improve by explanation: A more complete explanation of a technique can help inventors improve it systematically rather than relying on trial and error alone. — Social Science Bites Interview.
  17. Kranzberg's law: Mokyr cites Melvin Kranzberg's law that technology is neither simply good nor bad, and its consequences are not neutral. — Is Technology Our Enemy?.
  18. Unforeseen effects: Mokyr warns that technological change can produce benefits and harms, including effects that inventors did not foresee. — Is Technology Our Enemy?.

On Culture, Institutions, and the "Republic of Letters"

  1. Irreverence and inquiry: Mokyr argues that willingness to challenge established authority can help technological creativity, though it is not sufficient on its own. — A Culture of Growth.
  2. Question classical authority: Mokyr connects early-modern inquiry to a growing willingness to test inherited ideas against observation and evidence. — A Culture of Growth.
  3. Competition among ideas: Mokyr argues that rival centers of learning and patronage made it harder for one authority to stop heterodox inquiry across Europe. — Human Progress Interview.
  4. Mobility between states: Europe's competing polities gave some thinkers opportunities to relocate and continue their work when a local government tried to suppress it. — Human Progress Interview.
  5. Republic of Letters: Mokyr considers the Republic of Letters a major institution in the growth of useful knowledge, while also identifying other important institutions. — A Culture of Growth.
  6. A transnational network: The Republic of Letters connected scholars across political borders, letting ideas be shared, criticized and evaluated by a wider community. — The Market for Ideas.
  7. Escape local censorship: Mokyr argues that European political fragmentation allowed some scholars and writings to move when local authorities opposed their ideas. — A Culture of Growth.
  8. Not universal tolerance: Fragmentation did not make early Europe inherently tolerant; in Mokyr's account it made intolerance less effective over the long run. — A Culture of Growth.
  9. China and intellectual competition: In his historical comparison, Mokyr argues that competition in politics and the market for ideas was weaker in imperial China than in early-modern Europe. — A Culture of Growth.
  10. Barriers in China's market for ideas: Mokyr says Ming and Qing China had a market for ideas, but he argues its entry barriers and incumbent advantage constrained certain forms of intellectual change. — A Culture of Growth.
  11. Cultural entrepreneurs: Mokyr calls people who change others' beliefs cultural entrepreneurs and argues that such changes helped make inquiry and useful knowledge more valued. — Cultural Entrepreneurs.
  12. Bacon and Newton: Mokyr treats Francis Bacon and Isaac Newton as distinct figures who reshaped European ideas about knowledge and its practical value. — A Culture of Growth.
  13. Knowledge can accumulate: Mokyr traces a cultural shift toward treating knowledge as cumulative, open to correction and improvement by later generations. — A Culture of Growth.
  14. Open knowledge: For useful knowledge to keep accumulating, Mokyr emphasizes the value of open exchange and making discoveries accessible to others. — A Culture of Growth.
  15. Ideas and people move: Mokyr argues that mobility of ideas and the people generating them can sustain innovation across borders despite setbacks in any one country. — The Past and the Future of Innovation.
  16. Global versus local progress: Cross-border movement of researchers and ideas can protect global innovation, even though poor institutions may still harm progress in individual countries. — The Past and the Future of Innovation.
  17. Resistance to new ideas: Mokyr documents how established authorities and institutions could try to suppress unconventional ideas or redirect useful knowledge. — The Market for Ideas.
  18. Institutions can resist or reward: Sustained innovation depends partly on whether institutions reward inquiry and allow challengers to enter the market for ideas. — The Market for Ideas.
  19. Institutions can deteriorate: Mokyr warns that sound institutions can help prevent regression, but can also be replaced by worse ones. — Joel Mokyr Interview.
  20. Knowledge is not enough: Even as useful knowledge grows, Mokyr argues that political and social institutions affect whether societies turn it into lasting welfare gains. — Joel Mokyr Interview.

On the Future of Progress

  1. Learning capacity: Mokyr reported in 2022 that he saw no sign humanity's capacity to learn new things was slowing; this was his assessment, not a guarantee. — Joel Mokyr Interview.
  2. Knowledge as a growth driver: Mokyr linked continued discoveries in fields such as materials science and medicine to his optimism about future economic progress. — Joel Mokyr Interview.
  3. A historical welfare comparison: In a 2022 interview, Mokyr argued that despite pandemic-era hardship, a long-run historical comparison favored being born in the present. — Social Science Bites Interview.
  4. Long-run gains, uneven lives: Mokyr's broad historical comparison emphasizes gains in material welfare, while leaving room for serious present-day hardship and uneven benefits. — Social Science Bites Interview.
  5. Needs are not exhausted: Mokyr rejects the idea that existing consumer goods mean humanity has no further material needs. — Joel Mokyr Interview.
  6. New challenges create new needs: Mokyr points to climate change and adaptation as reasons societies still need innovation and resources. — Joel Mokyr Interview.
  7. Resources for solutions: Mokyr argues that tackling large contemporary problems will require creating resources as well as new solutions. — Joel Mokyr Interview.
  8. Pay for adaptation: In Mokyr's account, growth can generate resources needed for expensive climate adaptation; growth alone does not resolve the problem. — Joel Mokyr Interview.
  9. Technology and institutions: Mokyr saw no inherent technological reason for growth in economic welfare to slow, but warned that institutions could threaten its sustainability. — The Past and the Future of Innovation.
  10. Institutional risk: Mokyr's optimism about invention is conditional: political and social institutions can impede the conversion of new knowledge into welfare. — The Past and the Future of Innovation.
  11. Power is not welfare: Greater technological power does not automatically improve welfare; Mokyr stresses that consequences can be beneficial or harmful. — Is Technology Our Enemy?.
  12. Unintended harms: Mokyr documents technological bite-back: inventions can solve one problem while creating unanticipated costs. — Is Technology Our Enemy?.
  13. Agency shapes impact: For Mokyr, the effects of a technology depend partly on who decides to deploy it and on the institutions around that choice. — Is Technology Our Enemy?.
  14. Govern technological choices: Technology is not simply neutral: institutions and decision-makers influence who benefits and who bears harms. — Is Technology Our Enemy?.
  15. Better research methods: Mokyr notes that researchers continue to develop methods that expand what can be discovered, alongside new findings themselves. — Joel Mokyr Interview.
  16. Retrain displaced workers: In a later direct interview, Mokyr argues that workers whose skills are displaced by technology should be retrained where possible. — NewMoney Interview.
  17. Compensate those who cannot retrain: Mokyr also calls for compensation when technological change makes a worker's skills obsolete and retraining is not feasible; he says existing welfare states do this imperfectly. — NewMoney Interview.
  18. Keep enabling institutions: Mokyr argues that lasting progress requires knowledge, institutions that use it well, and a belief that improvement is possible. — Joel Mokyr Interview.

On the Study of History and Economics

  1. History and economics: Mokyr says he uses economics to understand history and history to understand economics. — Social Science Bites Interview.
  2. Complementary disciplines: His economic-history method combines historical evidence with economic questions rather than treating the disciplines as substitutes. — Social Science Bites Interview.
  3. Beware easy historical lessons: Mokyr warns that facile lessons from history can mislead because present circumstances differ from the past. — Social Science Bites Interview.
  4. Use history with care: Historical evidence can illuminate processes without supplying a ready-made prescription for today's choices. — Social Science Bites Interview.
  5. History crosses boundaries: Mokyr writes that the Industrial Revolution illustrates the limits of separating historical sciences into isolated compartments. — New Economic History and the Industrial Revolution.
  6. Study industrialization broadly: Mokyr treats the Industrial Revolution as a transformation involving work, family, culture, politics and knowledge as well as the economy. — New Economic History and the Industrial Revolution.
  7. Knowledge beyond commerce: Mokyr describes the Industrial Revolution as a shift toward growing knowledge of natural phenomena that could be harnessed for material welfare. — Social Science Bites Interview.
  8. Why understanding matters: In Mokyr's steel example, understanding why a material works makes deliberate improvement easier than relying on chance. — Social Science Bites Interview.
  9. Causal questions: Mokyr says causal inference has become central to economics and economic history. — Social Science Bites Interview.
  10. History as evidence: Economic historians seek large historical data sets to test explanations about development, while causal inference remains difficult. — Social Science Bites Interview.
  11. Ideas travel across borders: Mokyr argues that the international mobility of ideas and talent can widen the pool of useful knowledge available to innovators. — The Past and the Future of Innovation.
  12. Openness can aid invention: Mokyr's account gives open exchange of ideas a role in innovation; it does not establish that every country must import every technique to prosper. — The Past and the Future of Innovation.
  13. Institutions can misuse growth: Mokyr warns that bad governments can misallocate resources or use them to oppress people. — Joel Mokyr Interview.
  14. Governance shapes benefits: In Mokyr's account, technological and economic progress do not guarantee broad welfare when institutions channel gains toward oppression or a narrow group. — Joel Mokyr Interview.

Sources  

  1. Joel Mokyr on Economic Lessons from the Past — Social Science Bites
  2. Editor’s Introduction: The New Economic History and the Industrial Revolution — Joel Mokyr
  3. The Past and the Future of Innovation: Some Lessons from Economic History — Joel Mokyr
  4. Joel Mokyr: Progress is Human Made, but Not Predestined — Interview
  5. Is Technology Our Enemy? — Joel Mokyr
  6. Joel Mokyr on Greece’s Innovative Edge — NewMoney Interview
  7. A Culture of Growth: The Origins of the Modern Economy — Joel Mokyr
  8. The COVID Tonic: Joel Mokyr — Human Progress
  9. The Market for Ideas and the Great Enrichment — Joel Mokyr
  10. Cultural Entrepreneurs and the Origins of Modern Economic Growth — Joel Mokyr
  11. The Lever of Riches: Technological Creativity and Economic Progress — Joel Mokyr
  12. How Did We Get So Rich? — Building Tomorrow Interview
  13. The Future Economy — City Journal Interview
  14. Joel Mokyr — Northwestern Faculty Profile