Visual summary of operating lessons from Justin Mares.

Lessons from Justin Mares

Justin Mares co-authored Traction, helped build Kettle & Fire, Perfect Keto and Surely, and later founded Truemed. His work spans customer-acquisition experiments, consumer brands and payment access for qualifying prevention-related purchases. — Up Arrow Podcast.

Part 1: The Pursuit of Traction

  1. The 50 Percent Rule: The Traction co-authors recommend devoting comparable attention to building the product and finding customers, testing acquisition while product work is still underway. — Traction — Official Excerpt.
  2. What Traction Means: In Traction, Weinberg and Mares use customer growth as the practical signal that a startup is gaining traction; the channel work should be measured against that demand. — Traction — Official Excerpt.
  3. Customers, Not Just Product: The co-authors warn that building a product is insufficient if a startup cannot attract enough customers to sustain it. — Traction — Official Excerpt.
  4. Look Beyond Familiar Channels: The co-authors argue that underused acquisition channels can hold opportunities precisely because competitors often overlook them. — Traction — Official Excerpt.
  5. Test Channels Systematically: The Bullseye framework starts with a broad set of plausible traction channels, runs tests and then focuses effort on the most promising channel at the current stage. — Traction — Official Excerpt.
  6. Check Channel Bias: The co-authors caution founders against limiting experiments to channels they already know; unfamiliar channels may prove more effective. — Traction — Official Excerpt.

Part 2: Health and the Modern Environment

  1. The Zoo Analogy: Mares uses captive animals as an analogy for asking how a person's environment may shape health; it is a framing device, not proof of a specific disease mechanism. — The Great American Poisoning.
  2. A Food-System Critique: In a direct interview, Mares argues that incentives and the food environment contribute to poor health, framing the problem as systemic rather than purely individual. — Moth Fund Interview.
  3. Food-System Priorities: Mares argues that today's food system often favors yield, shelf stability and convenience over the nutrient density he values; this is his critique, not a measured claim that nutrient density has universally declined. — The Great American Poisoning.
  4. Regenerative Agriculture: Mares has expressed a preference for scaling organic and regenerative agriculture instead of relying primarily on newly engineered ingredients; that preference is not evidence of a clinical outcome. — The Next Brand #1.
  5. Environment and Chronic Disease: Mares argues that chronic disease should prompt scrutiny of food and lifestyle environments, rather than be treated solely as an individual's failure; this is his thesis, not settled proof of exclusive causation. — The Great American Poisoning.

Part 3: Building Consumer Brands

  1. Validate Demand Before Production: Mares tested Kettle & Fire demand with a landing page, PayPal checkout and small paid-search experiment before producing the broth, then informed early buyers when orders could not yet be fulfilled. — Kettle & Fire Validation.
  2. An Initially Modest Ambition: Before Kettle & Fire grew, Mares saw the bone-broth idea as a possible small business that could serve customers like him; he tested demand before assuming a larger opportunity. — The Next Brand #6.
  3. A Personal Product Gap: Nick Mares's knee injury and the brothers' difficulty finding prepared broth to their standards helped motivate Kettle & Fire; this origin story does not establish that broth speeds injury recovery. — Kettle & Fire Guide.
  4. Bootstrapping the First Years: Mares says Kettle & Fire was bootstrapped for almost its first two years, before outside fundraising helped it invest in a larger team. — Outlier Academy #144.
  5. Perfect Keto's Product Opportunity: Mares describes Perfect Keto as another consumer-health brand he built after Kettle & Fire, focused on products for a keto-oriented audience; the interview supports the business choice, not a claim of metabolic-health efficacy. — Outlier Academy #144.
  6. Surely's Non-Alcoholic Wine: Mares describes Surely as a way to offer non-alcoholic wine that people would enjoy drinking in social settings; the product thesis is distinct from a proven health outcome. — Outlier Academy #144.
  7. Start Online, Then Expand: Mares recounts selling Kettle & Fire directly online before expanding into retail distribution, where the business faced different operational demands. — Outlier Academy #144.
  8. Manufacturing Constraints: Mares says early co-packers resisted the broth's long cooking process, leading Kettle & Fire to solve production constraints and later invest more deeply in its supply chain. — New Ontologies Interview.
  9. Learning Across Ventures: Mares connects experience from Kettle & Fire, Perfect Keto and Surely with subsequent consumer-brand decisions; this is a learning pattern, not proof that later ventures are automatically safer. — Moth Fund Interview.

Part 4: Aligning Incentives in Healthcare

  1. Truemed's Prevention Thesis: Mares describes Truemed as an effort to move more health spending toward qualifying prevention-oriented purchases, rather than only downstream treatment. — New Ontologies Interview.
  2. A Critique of Treatment Incentives: Mares argues that American health spending often pays for treatment after illness while leaving preventive lifestyle purchases to consumers. This is his incentive critique, not proof that every preventive product works. — Up Arrow Podcast.
  3. Conditional HSA/FSA Access: Truemed provides a checkout and clinical-review pathway for eligible customers to use HSA or FSA funds on purchases that qualify as medical necessities; eligibility is not automatic. — Truemed — About.
  4. Medical Necessity Matters: Some lifestyle-related products may qualify for tax-advantaged HSA/FSA spending when tied to a specific condition and supported by appropriate medical documentation; categories alone do not make purchases eligible. — Truemed — About.
  5. Incentives for Prevention: Mares argues that current financing under-rewards prevention and wants payment infrastructure to make qualifying lifestyle interventions more accessible; his claim is a policy/business thesis, not a clinical comparison with pharmaceuticals. — New Ontologies Interview.
  6. A National-Security Frame: In an a16z conversation, Mares frames widespread chronic illness as a problem serious enough to warrant a national-security lens; the inherited bankruptcy wording and numerical hypothetical are not retained. — a16z Show — Health Crisis.
  7. Consumer-Directed Spending: Truemed's model lets qualifying consumers direct their own tax-advantaged funds toward eligible health-related purchases, subject to clinical review; it does not by itself establish that this is the fastest way to change medicine. — Truemed — About.
  8. A Financing Bottleneck: Mares sees out-of-pocket costs and eligibility rules as obstacles to prevention spending; Truemed addresses one part of that financing problem through conditional HSA/FSA access. — New Ontologies Interview.

Part 5: Playing Long-Term Games

  1. Value Long-Term Thinking: Mares has written that clear long-term thinking remains valuable when industries change quickly; his essay does not establish a three-year competitive threshold. — Mares — Writing.
  2. Beyond a Quick Exit: Reflecting on his early startup ambitions, Mares questioned whether selling a company for millions would be a satisfying goal and said money was not his strongest motivator at the time. — Mares — Writing.
  3. Patience in Physical Operations: Mares's Kettle & Fire account shows how long cook times, reluctant co-packers and supply-chain decisions made scaling a physical product an extended operational project. — New Ontologies Interview.
  4. The Bezos Example: Mares uses Bezos's publishing-rights negotiations as an example of thinking beyond an industry's current distribution model; this is Mares's interpretation of the Amazon story. — Mares — Writing.
  5. A Long Health-System Transition: Mares wrote in 2021 that he expected and hoped for a decades-long shift toward a food and healthcare system more oriented to health; this is a sector thesis, not a verified personal lifetime pledge. — The Next Brand #16.

Part 6: Navigating E-Commerce

  1. Learn Who Actually Buys: Mares says Kettle & Fire's early branding targeted customers like himself, but the actual buyers differed, leading the team to soften its packaging and messaging. — Outlier Academy #144.
  2. Bring Digital Testing to CPG: Mares tested Kettle & Fire demand online with a landing page and small paid-search spend before committing to production, applying an experiment-led growth approach to a physical product. — Kettle & Fire Validation.
  3. Retail Changes the Operating Model: Mares recounts Kettle & Fire moving from a fully direct-to-consumer launch into Whole Foods and other wholesale channels, changing the mix and economics of distribution. — Outlier Academy #144.
  4. Product Standards as Differentiation: Nick and Justin Mares say they could not find a prepared broth matching their preferred ingredients and packaging, so they built Kettle & Fire around those standards; transparency alone is not shown to win a market. — Kettle & Fire Guide.
  5. Finance Becomes Operational Infrastructure: Mares says Kettle & Fire's weak early financial controls left substantial invoices uncollected and made cash flow dangerous; he came to treat finance and experienced operators as strategic to scaling. — Outlier Academy #144.
  6. Serve Emerging Niches: Mares looks for small but growing consumer needs that larger food companies may neglect, seeing an opening for focused new brands rather than immediately chasing the mass market. — The Next Brand #8.

Part 7: Personal Optimization and Philosophy

  1. Work on a Mission You Care About: Mares says the difficulty of building a startup has made mission alignment important to him; after Kettle & Fire and Truemed, he would not want to start a company whose mission he did not care about. — From Start-Up to Grown-Up #122.
  2. Choose the Problems You Want to Solve: Mares distinguishes the hard business problems he enjoys—such as building a novel supply chain or prevention-payment system—from avoidable problems caused by underinvesting in experienced teammates. — Up Arrow Podcast.
  3. Step Back from Outrage Media: Mares has written that he sometimes withdraws from social platforms and news cycles because he finds their outrage incentives distracting; this is his information-diet choice. — The Next Brand #8.
  4. Personal Health Experiments: Mares says he tries health-related changes on himself to learn what seems useful for him; personal observations do not establish clinical efficacy or general advice. — Up Arrow Podcast.
  5. Build Competence Through Smaller Ventures: Mares advises many early entrepreneurs to build a real business and develop competence before taking on far larger ambitions; he does not claim this removes later risk. — Moth Fund Interview.
  6. Question System Incentives: Mares has publicly challenged incentives in food production and healthcare financing and has tried to build businesses around those problems; the specific health mechanisms remain his thesis. — The Great American Poisoning.
  7. Build Around Mission Alignment: Mares says a strong reason for doing the work matters to him and to the early team he hires; the original contrast with merely criticizing systems online is not directly supported. — From Start-Up to Grown-Up #122.
  8. Explore Emerging Health Ideas Cautiously: Mares has expressed interest in metabolic psychiatry and light exposure as emerging areas to investigate. His predictions are hypotheses, not established evidence that alternative protocols outperform standard care. — The Next #53.

Part 8: The Reality of Entrepreneurship

  1. Match Ambition with Feedback: Mares cautions young founders that an endeavor so difficult it yields no positive feedback can undermine confidence and learning; he favors a path that develops competence first. — Moth Fund Interview.
  2. Experience Does Not Erase Uncertainty: Across successive companies, Mares says he learned to trust his judgment more, while still facing doubt and hard decisions; repeat founding does not make the initial friction disappear. — From Start-Up to Grown-Up #122.
  3. Start Small to Build Momentum: Mares describes startups as momentum games: beginning with a simple test can reveal opportunities that were not obvious before launch. — From Start-Up to Grown-Up #122.
  4. Handle Founder Doubt Concretely: Mares says he still experiences self-doubt and finds it useful to shift from abstract future worries to a specific problem the team can solve today. — From Start-Up to Grown-Up #122.
  5. Trust Judgment While Testing: Mares says he wishes he had trusted his own judgment earlier, even as he sought advice; his accounts also show him testing ideas rather than substituting conviction for data. — From Start-Up to Grown-Up #122.
  6. Revisit Channels as the Company Grows: The Traction co-authors argue that the most useful customer-acquisition channel can change with a startup's stage, so founders should revisit their channel focus as they scale. — Traction — Official Excerpt.